[ultimateclassicrock.com]

Don't forget to vote !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Where's Adolfo fito de la Parra ?

2 1 2 0

I voted. I see the enxt one is Bonham vs A van Halen. That has got to be a joke, right? One of the best vs one of the worst.

Quote
Palace Revolution 2000
I voted. I see the enxt one is Bonham vs A van Halen. That has got to be a joke, right? One of the best vs one of the worst.

is your post some kind of joke? alex van halen one of the worst drummers in rock

Never heard of Bunny Carlos before...

Easy win for Charlie.

Mitch Mitchel is in the list. I think that's a little comforting for our Charlie.
Otherwise this list is rather poor, don't you think?
(Well Bonham could be regarded as quite accomplished, but I never liked his style).

Where are Mick Fleetwood, Ginger Baker, Ringo, Clem Burke, just to name a few?




Just as long as the guitar plays, let it steal your heart away

Bun E Carlos all the way..... Cheap Trick

It's a Classic Rock contest, so why is Charlie even in the contest, he's not a rock drummer at all ?

Narwhal fight!! Narwhal fight!!

What a stupid, disjointed collection of drummers. Horrible.

Agreed other than Charlie. Bonham was a joke. AV Halen????Tommy Lee?? Whats??????????

Quote
alhavu1
Agreed other than Charlie. Bonham was a joke. AV Halen????Tommy Lee?? Whats??????????

Bonham was a JOKE?? C'mon now, that's crazy talk. AVH is amazing as well.

I didn't mean to imply that the other drummers on that list were necessarily BAD...just that it was a really random collection of drummers with no discernable logic.

BAM BAM BAM. Analogy is those freakin guitar players who think speed and a zillion notes = talent. Subtlety, baby, subtlety

.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2015-03-28 04:46 by camper88.

Charlie will beat Bun E. of course, but in the final round he'll lose to John Bonham.

This is a classic rock site, so it's going to be skewed in favour of Led Zeppelinites.

..unless we all keep voting

I wouldn't call either the Stones or LZ classic rock.

Quote
DandelionPowderman
I wouldn't call either the Stones or LZ classic rock.

but you're from Norway, so you're excused.

Watts vs Carlos ?!? That's rubbish!

Quote
treaclefingers

Quote
DandelionPowderman
I wouldn't call either the Stones or LZ classic rock.

but you're from Norway, so you're excused.

lol. They are probably the two most played bands on "classic rock" stations here in America. Curious what you'd consider classic rock in Norway and if the Stones and LZ aren't classic rock, what are they?

Agree (once again) with treacle that Bonham will win out over Watts in the final round.

peace

Charlie is by far the best drummer on this list, including John Bonham and Mitch Mitchell. But Cheap Trick is still pretty spry live in 2015- forget the crap 80's/90's stuff- check Bun E. and the boys, raucous-

[www.youtube.com]

[retrainyourbraintohappiness.blogspot.be]

Quote
roryfaninva
Charlie is by far the best drummer on this list, including John Bonham and Mitch Mitchell. But Cheap Trick is still pretty spry live in 2015- forget the crap 80's/90's stuff- check Bun E. and the boys, raucous-

[www.youtube.com]

Unfortunately Bun E. Carlos has been out of Cheap Trick since 2010.

So I've heard-not a huge Cheap Trick fan but IMHO that performance is a corker (and while he's no Charlie Watts and never will be, its sounds pretty good)

Isn't Charlie more of a percussionist? He makes the crossover from Stones to jazz pretty easily. I doubt that Tommy Lee, or any of the others can do that.

[www.gq.com]

KEITH MOON

Quote
Munichhilton
Narwhal fight!! Narwhal fight!!

Hoping to see a slip of the blow hole!