For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
RomanCandleQuote
strat72Quote
RomanCandle
I'm a much bigger troll than Lou Reed ever was when it comes to talk about music, but... I don't get the Yeezus hate, and I'm not even joking.
It was great trolling by Lou........ Very obvious for people that enjoy ironic humour, yet subtle enough to take some people in!
Classic Lou Reed.
You're teaching your grandmother to suck eggs...
But when Lou Reed wrote that Kanye West was talented, he did mean it!
Quote
BowieStoneQuote
strat72Quote
BowieStoneQuote
whitem8
Morning Phase by Beck? All songs written and produced by Beck. Beyonce's self-titled album? Four featured guest artists, seventeen producers, and twenty-five (count 'em!) different songwriters. Kanye's Jeezus? Over 20 producers and more than 40 songwriters. I guess my definition of "artistry" is different than Kanye's.
Who cares? I want to hear a good album. If it's one producer: fine. 105 producers? Fine too. There's a Producer of the Year award for that.
I think Kanye's point is that the Beck album didn't make any impact. At any level. Sure, it might be a good album but no one cares/cared. That really can't be an album of the year. It'll fall in the category of Herbie Hancock, Steely Dan, Robert Plant/Alison Kraus: fine albums, but we'll only remember them because of the Grammy Awards, not because they were so great.
While the Beyonce album was an event. Even artisically, no matter how many producers... It's a pretty terrific r&b album.
Well I cared about Becks new album..... I've been playing it since it's release.
Bowiestone...... When is the new Miley album due?
I'll check that for you grandpa.
Quote
RomanCandleQuote
rollmops
I am happy that Beck won because his record "Morning Phase" is great. Maybe not for everybody's taste but he made a well crafted album with beautiful melodies, harmonies and amazing musical arrangments. It's low key but very sincere and effective on the brain. No pretentious crap like Kanye West's overrated and auto tune bullshit.
Rock and roll,
Mops
Overrated?
Quote
strat72Quote
RomanCandle
I'm a much bigger troll than Lou Reed ever was when it comes to talk about music, but... I don't get the Yeezus hate, and I'm not even joking.
It was great trolling by Lou........ Very obvious for people that enjoy ironic humour, yet subtle enough to take some people in!
Classic Lou Reed.
Quote
stupidguy2
Kanye is obnoxious, but that doesn't mean he isn't a valid artist.
I laugh when fans of groups like the Stones sneer at younger artists for being arrogant or entititled..
That's funny to me.
Anyway, my favorite Grammy performance was Miranda Lambert kicking ass...
Quote
GasLightStreetQuote
stupidguy2
Kanye is obnoxious, but that doesn't mean he isn't a valid artist.
I laugh when fans of groups like the Stones sneer at younger artists for being arrogant or entititled..
That's funny to me.
Anyway, my favorite Grammy performance was Miranda Lambert kicking ass...
Valid artist? What do you call Axl Rose then?
Valid doesn't equal good. Kanye SUCKS. And on top of that he's a complete... dickhead.
Quote
GasLightStreetQuote
stupidguy2
Kanye is obnoxious, but that doesn't mean he isn't a valid artist.
I laugh when fans of groups like the Stones sneer at younger artists for being arrogant or entititled..
That's funny to me.
Anyway, my favorite Grammy performance was Miranda Lambert kicking ass...
Valid artist? What do you call Axl Rose then?
Valid doesn't equal good. Kanye SUCKS. And on top of that he's a complete... dickhead.
Quote
treaclefingersQuote
GasLightStreetQuote
stupidguy2
Kanye is obnoxious, but that doesn't mean he isn't a valid artist.
I laugh when fans of groups like the Stones sneer at younger artists for being arrogant or entititled..
That's funny to me.
Anyway, my favorite Grammy performance was Miranda Lambert kicking ass...
Valid artist? What do you call Axl Rose then?
Valid doesn't equal good. Kanye SUCKS. And on top of that he's a complete... dickhead.
He seems to inspire a lot of people so although I have absolutely no interest in him or his music whatsoever, doesn't mean he isn't an artist.
Unfortunately for him, whether or not he's a good artist will always be overshadowed by his narcissistic dickheadedness. An 'entitled' stupid moron.
Well that is your take on it and mine is very different. I findQuote
BowieStoneQuote
whitem8
Morning Phase by Beck? All songs written and produced by Beck. Beyonce's self-titled album? Four featured guest artists, seventeen producers, and twenty-five (count 'em!) different songwriters. Kanye's Jeezus? Over 20 producers and more than 40 songwriters. I guess my definition of "artistry" is different than Kanye's.
Who cares? I want to hear a good album. If it's one producer: fine. 105 producers? Fine too. There's a Producer of the Year award for that.
I think Kanye's point is that the Beck album didn't make any impact. At any level. Sure, it might be a good album but no one cares/cared. That really can't be an album of the year. It'll fall in the category of Herbie Hancock, Steely Dan, Robert Plant/Alison Kraus: fine albums, but we'll only remember them because of the Grammy Awards, not because they were so great.
While the Beyonce album was an event. Even artisically, no matter how many producers... It's a pretty terrific r&b album.
Quote
whitem8Well that is your take on it and mine is very different. I findQuote
BowieStoneQuote
whitem8
Morning Phase by Beck? All songs written and produced by Beck. Beyonce's self-titled album? Four featured guest artists, seventeen producers, and twenty-five (count 'em!) different songwriters. Kanye's Jeezus? Over 20 producers and more than 40 songwriters. I guess my definition of "artistry" is different than Kanye's.
Who cares? I want to hear a good album. If it's one producer: fine. 105 producers? Fine too. There's a Producer of the Year award for that.
I think Kanye's point is that the Beck album didn't make any impact. At any level. Sure, it might be a good album but no one cares/cared. That really can't be an album of the year. It'll fall in the category of Herbie Hancock, Steely Dan, Robert Plant/Alison Kraus: fine albums, but we'll only remember them because of the Grammy Awards, not because they were so great.
While the Beyonce album was an event. Even artisically, no matter how many producers... It's a pretty terrific r&b album.
albums with multiple writers and producers more of a commercial packaged designed to sell with maximum effect and little artistry from the maker (s). Beck's album made a big impact on people who like his music, and was universally liked by top critics. And again, he WROTE his music and plays instruments and creates vivid soundscapes that provoke emotional responses and thoughts. But I am not a fan of rap or faux r n b at all. I find the new age r n b is just an excuse for vocal histrionics and loud brach sterile music. A far cry from the days of Stax and Atlantic records. I do not think West's or Beyonce's album to be terrific at all. I find them boring cliches of commercialised American Idol music that has become an insipid infection in the music industry. Plus, it just sucks and sounds like shit.
Quote
whitem8Quote
BowieStoneQuote
whitem8
Morning Phase by Beck? All songs written and produced by Beck. Beyonce's self-titled album? Four featured guest artists, seventeen producers, and twenty-five (count 'em!) different songwriters. Kanye's Jeezus? Over 20 producers and more than 40 songwriters. I guess my definition of "artistry" is different than Kanye's.
Who cares? I want to hear a good album. If it's one producer: fine. 105 producers? Fine too. There's a Producer of the Year award for that.
I think Kanye's point is that the Beck album didn't make any impact. At any level. Sure, it might be a good album but no one cares/cared. That really can't be an album of the year. It'll fall in the category of Herbie Hancock, Steely Dan, Robert Plant/Alison Kraus: fine albums, but we'll only remember them because of the Grammy Awards, not because they were so great.
While the Beyonce album was an event. Even artisically, no matter how many producers... It's a pretty terrific r&b album.
Well that is your take on it and mine is very different. I find albums with multiple writers and producers more of a commercial packaged designed to sell with maximum effect and little artistry from the maker (s). Beck's album made a big impact on people who like his music, and was universally liked by top critics. And again, he WROTE his music and plays instruments and creates vivid soundscapes that provoke emotional responses and thoughts. But I am not a fan of rap or faux r n b at all. I find the new age r n b is just an excuse for vocal histrionics and loud brach sterile music. A far cry from the days of Stax and Atlantic records. I do not think West's or Beyonce's album to be terrific at all. I find them boring cliches of commercialised American Idol music that has become an insipid infection in the music industry. Plus, it just sucks and sounds like shit.
Quote
whitem8
Well that is your take on it and mine is very different. I find
albums with multiple writers and producers more of a commercial packaged designed to sell with maximum effect and little artistry from the maker (s). Beck's album made a big impact on people who like his music, and was universally liked by top critics. And again, he WROTE his music and plays instruments and creates vivid soundscapes that provoke emotional responses and thoughts. But I am not a fan of rap or faux r n b at all. I find the new age r n b is just an excuse for vocal histrionics and loud brach sterile music. A far cry from the days of Stax and Atlantic records. I do not think West's or Beyonce's album to be terrific at all. I find them boring cliches of commercialised American Idol music that has become an insipid infection in the music industry. Plus, it just sucks and sounds like shit.
Quote
whitem8
Beck's album made a big impact on people who like his music, and was universally liked by top critics.
Quote
Rockman
Okay start writin' ... we'll all wait here
Quote
BowieStone
Beyoncé has a team looking for 14 dope beats, she puts some lyrics to them and there you go.
Quote
stupidguy2Quote
treaclefingersQuote
GasLightStreetQuote
stupidguy2
Kanye is obnoxious, but that doesn't mean he isn't a valid artist.
I laugh when fans of groups like the Stones sneer at younger artists for being arrogant or entititled..
That's funny to me.
Anyway, my favorite Grammy performance was Miranda Lambert kicking ass...
Valid artist? What do you call Axl Rose then?
Valid doesn't equal good. Kanye SUCKS. And on top of that he's a complete... dickhead.
He seems to inspire a lot of people so although I have absolutely no interest in him or his music whatsoever, doesn't mean he isn't an artist.
Unfortunately for him, whether or not he's a good artist will always be overshadowed by his narcissistic dickheadedness. An 'entitled' stupid moron.
I agree, but just don't like the blanket fossilized 'new=music=sucks' mantra that some older fans throw out there to every young artist who isn't Ryan Adams or some other 'indie' fave.
KW may not be to everyone's taste, but to suggest that Lou Reed was 'joking' about his admiration for Yeezus is absurd and the height of old fart delusion.
Besides, I really wanted to give a shout-out to Miranda Lambert!
Quote
dcbaQuote
BowieStone
Beyoncé has a team looking for 14 dope beats, she puts some lyrics to them and there you go.
That's very interesting cos it's basically how capitalism/big corps works these days.
They basically outsource everything they can so they don't create anything & they slap their brand name on the stuff they bought left and right... just like Beyoncé?
Quote
stupidguy2Quote
treaclefingersQuote
GasLightStreetQuote
stupidguy2
Kanye is obnoxious, but that doesn't mean he isn't a valid artist.
I laugh when fans of groups like the Stones sneer at younger artists for being arrogant or entititled..
That's funny to me.
Anyway, my favorite Grammy performance was Miranda Lambert kicking ass...
Valid artist? What do you call Axl Rose then?
Valid doesn't equal good. Kanye SUCKS. And on top of that he's a complete... dickhead.
He seems to inspire a lot of people so although I have absolutely no interest in him or his music whatsoever, doesn't mean he isn't an artist.
Unfortunately for him, whether or not he's a good artist will always be overshadowed by his narcissistic dickheadedness. An 'entitled' stupid moron.
I agree, but just don't like the blanket fossilized 'new=music=sucks' mantra that some older fans throw out there to every young artist who isn't Ryan Adams or some other 'indie' fave.
KW may not be to everyone's taste, but to suggest that Lou Reed was 'joking' about his admiration for Yeezus is absurd and the height of old fart delusion.
Besides, I really wanted to give a shout-out to Miranda Lambert!
Quote
GasLightStreetQuote
stupidguy2Quote
treaclefingersQuote
GasLightStreetQuote
stupidguy2
Kanye is obnoxious, but that doesn't mean he isn't a valid artist.
I laugh when fans of groups like the Stones sneer at younger artists for being arrogant or entititled..
That's funny to me.
Anyway, my favorite Grammy performance was Miranda Lambert kicking ass...
Valid artist? What do you call Axl Rose then?
Valid doesn't equal good. Kanye SUCKS. And on top of that he's a complete... dickhead.
He seems to inspire a lot of people so although I have absolutely no interest in him or his music whatsoever, doesn't mean he isn't an artist.
Unfortunately for him, whether or not he's a good artist will always be overshadowed by his narcissistic dickheadedness. An 'entitled' stupid moron.
I agree, but just don't like the blanket fossilized 'new=music=sucks' mantra that some older fans throw out there to every young artist who isn't Ryan Adams or some other 'indie' fave.
KW may not be to everyone's taste, but to suggest that Lou Reed was 'joking' about his admiration for Yeezus is absurd and the height of old fart delusion.
Besides, I really wanted to give a shout-out to Miranda Lambert!
In one aspect you're spot on - not all new music sucks. Or however you want to put it. It's just that when someone is clearly talentless and a complete moron, like Kanye West, that doesn't mean one is an old fart by rote because they don't like them/it/him/her. It just means he sucks. If you want to defend his stance as an artist and blah blah blah it comes off as shining a turd. Calling Kanye West an artist is a defiling of the term artist. You might as well say Mark Gormley is just as much of an artist as Kanye West.
Quote
mighty stork
Quote
GasLightStreet
It's just that when someone is clearly talentless and a complete moron,
Quote
AquamarineQuote
GasLightStreet
It's just that when someone is clearly talentless and a complete moron,
Moron, yes. COMPLETE moron, no. Because, clearly talented at a. music, b. self-publicity, c. music, d. making money, by selling lots of e. music.
Extremely flawed genius, like most of them.