For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
pmk251
Why leave out 1970? Especially Lennon's POB? It's one of the most powerful and beautiful albums ever released. I heard or read somewhere (a long time ago) that if you wanted the next Beatles record, just combine their solo records because that was how they were recording at the end. I tried it and could not get it to work. "McCartney", Harrison's "ATMP" and Lennon's "POB" are such divergent works. The track transitions are too startling. Besides, I remember little I wanted to include from "McCartney" and the song balance was off.
Quote
dave9199Quote
Irix
D1 - Goodnight Vienna (R. Starkey & J. Lennon)
Goodnight Vienna is by Lennon only.
Quote
pmk251
Why leave out 1970? Especially Lennon's POB?
Quote
Irix
From the Book (p. 180) -- "The Green Album" :
A1 - All Things Must Pass (G. Harrison)
A2 - It Don’t Come Easy (R. Starkey)
A3 - Isn’t It A Pity (G. Harrison)
A4 - Maybe I’m Amazed (P. McCartney)
A5 - Instant Karma (J. Lennon)
B1 - Back Off Boogaloo (R. Starkey)
B2 - My Love (P. McCartney)
B3 - Jealous Guy (J. Lennon)
B4 - Living In The Material World (G. Harrison)
B5 - Imagine (J. Lennon)
C1 - Photograph (R. Starkey & G. Harrison)
C2 - Mind Games (J. Lennon)
C3 - Jet (P. McCartney)
C4 - Don't Let Me Wait Too Long (G. Harrison)
C5 - Band On The Run (P. McCartney)
D1 - Goodnight Vienna (R. Starkey & J. Lennon)
D2 - Helen Wheels (P. McCartney)
D3 - So Sad (G. Harrison)
D4 - Whatever Gets You Thru The Night (J. Lennon)
D5 - Junior's Farm (P. McCartney)
(Names = Performers)
Quote
stonehearted
Band On The Roof.
Quote
dave9199
I don't think as many people will know about the book download.
Quote
dave9199
I will say yes I would include songs from Milk & Honey on it for anyone who would do it.
Quote
DrPete
This is awesome news. I guess we have to wait till 1969 to have the Let It Be movie Finally released
Funny thing is, I've watched this ROW between them dozens of time and really just don't see how controversial it was. I have had worse rows with my family and friends weekly for my entire life, lol. Yes 2019 HaQuote
stoneheartedQuote
DrPete
This is awesome news. I guess we have to wait till 1969 to have the Let It Be movie Finally released
I'm sure 1969 will be a very good year for music.
But seriously, with Paul at the helm I'm sure he'll edit things a bit so he doesn't look bad, like the row with George that was caught on camera.
Quote
DrPeteFunny thing is, I've watched this ROW between them dozens of time and really just don't see how controversial it was. I have had worse rows with my family and friends weekly for my entire life, lol. Yes 2019 HaQuote
stoneheartedQuote
DrPete
This is awesome news. I guess we have to wait till 1969 to have the Let It Be movie Finally released
I'm sure 1969 will be a very good year for music.
But seriously, with Paul at the helm I'm sure he'll edit things a bit so he doesn't look bad, like the row with George that was caught on camera.
Quote
HairballQuote
DrPeteFunny thing is, I've watched this ROW between them dozens of time and really just don't see how controversial it was. I have had worse rows with my family and friends weekly for my entire life, lol. Yes 2019 HaQuote
stoneheartedQuote
DrPete
This is awesome news. I guess we have to wait till 1969 to have the Let It Be movie Finally released
I'm sure 1969 will be a very good year for music.
But seriously, with Paul at the helm I'm sure he'll edit things a bit so he doesn't look bad, like the row with George that was caught on camera.
Yes it seems to be some very minor squabbling amongst band members.
Quote
stonehearted
Yes, Paul wants him to play something and to reinforce his point he recalls how George wanted to play accenting guitar lines in Hey Jude, and here is a clip of that moment: [www.youtube.com]
Quote
stonehearted
Yes, Paul wants him to play something and to reinforce his point he recalls how George wanted to play accenting guitar lines in Hey Jude, and here is a clip of that moment: [www.youtube.com]
Quote
RollingFreak
Yeah, as I said, I don't see any of it as "controversial" as many have claimed, but that key part of "I'll play whatever you want, or I won't play at all...whatever it is that will please you, I'll do it". While its incredibly interesting to watch, I do feel like we're also not supposed to be there, and certainly that they shared that opinion later in life. Its cool to be the fly on the wall, but its also at a time when maybe there shouldn't have been. Its not like anyone punched anyone, but it certainly paints certain people in poor lights, but thats just how it is being in the studio, working on a film set, etc. Its a high pressure environment, and you need that to create a good product, but you don't necessarily need it on film for everyone to see. For that reason, I don't see it coming out, but maybe I'm wrong. I like the idea of being in the studio with them. I think that was the wrong album to do it on, and when you watch it its not "bad" or "embarrassing" but I do feel there's a sense of "I shouldn't be here. This is their thing that only truly makes sense to them." Its not really sessions meant for our entertainment, which is why I see why its been held back.