For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
OutOfTimeQuote
dcbaQuote
marclaff
Personally, i've a problem with Dead Flowers "alternate".
It doesn't sound like a demo or a studio version.
For me it's completely live (near the Texas 72 version) :
Rehearsals before a tour (70, 71 or even 72)?
Live known version with audience unheard ?
Live unknown version ?
What do you think...
Certainly no studio outtake. To me it sounds like a rehearsal for the Marquee Club show in 1971.
Marquee or a pre-show 1970 soundcheck/rehearsal? Malmoe'70 or another gig?
Or (let's be adventurous) a pre-show soundcheck/rehearsal for the Saville Theatre or the Lyceum Theatre late 1969 shows...?
I imagine that :
they had recorded DF (acoustic version) in the studio a few days before and at the Saville or the Lyceum someone (Keith?) decided to try the song in an all electric arrangement.
It worked pretty well so they kept the idea for the following tour (Euro 1970) or as there are no setlists for these London'69 it's possible they tested an electric DF live at these London shows.
Why put on the SF reissue a live/soundcheck version? Because the alt. studio version of DF has been bootlegged since 1992 ("Time Trip" vol.1/2) and it's not drastically different from the SF version. Hence the finding of this electric take.
And Herr Zentgraf has an entry on 1969-12-14 which he describes as "Rehearsals for the upcoming shows" so I'd place the DF version as stemming from this!
Like my theory?
Quote
muenkeQuote
dcba
Herr Zentgraf has an entry on 1969-12-14 which he describes as "Rehearsals for the upcoming shows" so I'd place the DF version as stemming from this!
Like my theory?
I agree. This version of Dead Flowers sounds like a rehearsal for a show. Only question is which show. We know for sure the Marquee rehearsals were recorded and filmed.
Quote
dcbaQuote
muenkeQuote
dcba
Herr Zentgraf has an entry on 1969-12-14 which he describes as "Rehearsals for the upcoming shows" so I'd place the DF version as stemming from this!
Like my theory?
I agree. This version of Dead Flowers sounds like a rehearsal for a show. Only question is which show. We know for sure the Marquee rehearsals were recorded and filmed.
A live rehearsal with 3 guitars??? Two of them sounding like Taylor?? No way!
Quote
charliesgood
you know I just got the latest tull release which includes a nice booklet a live show unreleased songs and two dvds with hi res options for 40 bucks .For this superdeluxe edition you are paying over a hundred extra bucks for a booklet and the leeds disc seems a little excessive btw you can the booklet and the marque dvd at best buy for 35 bucks
Quote
sweet neo con
were the only special issues....the Best Buy Cd Single with Tshirt and Target Deluxe 2 disk SF plus vinyl Album? just wondering. thanks
Quote
kovach
So is the Super Deluxe limited edition? And if so how many?
Quote
DrPete
Anyone know if it will be available on HD tracks?
Quote
SonicDreamer
Hi all,
Is this review by Paul Simister from amazon.co.uk accurate, i.e. all the material is available elsewhere?
Paul Simister amazon.co.uk Sticky Fingers (Super Deluxe) Review
If so, I ain't gonna be buying this until the price drops.
Cheers,
SonicD
Quote
SonicDreamer
Hi all,
Is this review by Paul Simister from amazon.co.uk accurate, i.e. all the material is available elsewhere?
Paul Simister amazon.co.uk Sticky Fingers (Super Deluxe) Review
If so, I ain't gonna be buying this until the price drops.
Cheers,
SonicD
Quote
mitchQuote
SonicDreamer
Hi all,
Is this review by Paul Simister from amazon.co.uk accurate, i.e. all the material is available elsewhere?
Paul Simister amazon.co.uk Sticky Fingers (Super Deluxe) Review
If so, I ain't gonna be buying this until the price drops.
Cheers,
SonicD
If this guy is unable to make the diffence between a 1969 live version of "Live With Me" or "Stray Cat Blues" and 1971 ones, it is hopeless.
This guy has obviously a really poor ear and knowledge of stones music.
One of the stupiest and useless review i have read since a long time.
Thanks for the link, always funny to read.
Quote
SonicDreamer
Hi all,
Is this review by Paul Simister from amazon.co.uk accurate, i.e. all the material is available elsewhere?
Paul Simister amazon.co.uk Sticky Fingers (Super Deluxe) Review
If so, I ain't gonna be buying this until the price drops.
Cheers,
SonicD
Quote
Father TedQuote
SonicDreamer
Hi all,
Is this review by Paul Simister from amazon.co.uk accurate, i.e. all the material is available elsewhere?
Paul Simister amazon.co.uk Sticky Fingers (Super Deluxe) Review
If so, I ain't gonna be buying this until the price drops.
Cheers,
SonicD
No, he's quite wrong. The Roundhouse show has never been released before, nor has the Leeds show.
Quote
hockenheim95Quote
Father TedQuote
SonicDreamer
Hi all,
Is this review by Paul Simister from amazon.co.uk accurate, i.e. all the material is available elsewhere?
Paul Simister amazon.co.uk Sticky Fingers (Super Deluxe) Review
If so, I ain't gonna be buying this until the price drops.
Cheers,
SonicD
No, he's quite wrong. The Roundhouse show has never been released before, nor has the Leeds show.
I think he means that the same songs are on YaYas
Quote
SonicDreamer
Hi all,
Is this review by Paul Simister from amazon.co.uk accurate, i.e. all the material is available elsewhere?
Paul Simister amazon.co.uk Sticky Fingers (Super Deluxe) Review
If so, I ain't gonna be buying this until the price drops.
Cheers,
SonicD
Quote
kowalskiQuote
SonicDreamer
Hi all,
Is this review by Paul Simister from amazon.co.uk accurate, i.e. all the material is available elsewhere?
Paul Simister amazon.co.uk Sticky Fingers (Super Deluxe) Review
If so, I ain't gonna be buying this until the price drops.
Cheers,
SonicD
I think it's a fair review given the price asked for the super deluxe box set. He doesn't say that the same material is available elsewhere, he says the set lists between 1969 and 1973 look quite similar and this particular concert from 1971 is maybe not the best of the three (GYYYO, Leeds and Brussels). If you already have GYYYO ad Brussels Affair maybe you don't need to pay £72,99 for this one. As the reviewer says, if you're a Stones fan you already know you need this concert, if not maybe you can skip this one or just get the mp3 version...
Quote
hockenheim95
I think he means that the same songs are on YaYas
Quote
kowalskiQuote
IrixQuote
milio77
And maybe give it a try at 7 digital...
If you try Qobuz and buy the lossless FLAC/WAV format, then you can additionally download the lossy 320kps AAC/MP3 version. This makes sense if you want the lossless FLAC/WAV for the HDD-Player plus the lossy 320kps AAC/MP3 for the Smartphone/Tablet - and you don't have to convert it by yourself ....
(Qobuz is available in France, Germany, Austria, Switzerland, BeNeLux, UK, Ireland)
That's why Qobuz has currently the best offer. If you buy a CD quality download (FLAC, AIFF, WAV, etc) you also get the AAC (iTunes) version and the MP3 (Google Play) version for the same price.
Quote
DandelionPowderman
I purchased the Treacle Fingers LP set today. £30, shipping included. I don't know if that's expensive, but I'm just glad I managed to get this one, as I thought I had missed this limited release.
I bought it here: [www.recordstore.co.uk]