bill or keith or ronnie on bass?
ian mclagan or billy preston on the hammond?

…for sure:
charlie on drums!

bobby on sax?

This sounds a bit like Emotional Rescue sped up or Letterman's house band jamming. Doesn't sound like the Stones at all to me.

Mick must have been off growing his beard.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2013-03-05 15:38 by punkfloyd.

"ian mclagan or billy preston on the hammond?"

With the "1978" tag you have your own answer...

780823A 23rd August - 8th September: Los Angeles, RCA Studios. Producers: The Glimmer Twins & Chris Kimsey.
Sound engineers: Chris Kimsey, Alex Vertikoff. Additional musicians: Ian McLagan (p, org)/Bobby Keys (sax)/Jim Keltner (perc)

- Knee Trembler (MJ/KR) -instrumental jam with sax

[www.nzentgraf.de]

I always thought it´s Keith on bass

Quote
alfstone
I always thought it´s Keith on bass

That's possible

It's Charlie allright, reminds me a bit of like Little T&A.

Quote
alfstone
I always thought it´s Keith on bass

i don´t think so. bass playing is way too good. It also doesn´t sound like Ronnie (compare with fingerprint file)
All that slapping disco stuff - that´s surely bill.

Bills not on bass,,,keith or ronnie or even mick.

Quote
deardoctor

Quote
alfstone
I always thought it´s Keith on bass

i don´t think so. bass playing is way too good. It also doesn´t sound like Ronnie (compare with fingerprint file)
All that slapping disco stuff - that´s surely bill.

Perhaps its Don Was?

Quote
deardoctor

Quote
alfstone
I always thought it´s Keith on bass

i don´t think so. bass playing is way too good. It also doesn´t sound like Ronnie (compare with fingerprint file)
All that slapping disco stuff - that´s surely bill.

The bass has to be Keith. It sounds like it's played with a plectrum, and it's also the lead stringed instrument--Bill would never play lead bass. This tune was obviously composed from the bass, therefore Keith.

Funny kind of jam for Stones members. It sounds like something the Saturday Night Live house band would play through a commercial break.

It' Keith all right...

It kind of reminds me of the Meters.

I'd say Ronnie on bass. Too many runs in it. And, Ron did do the Emotional Rescue bass after all.

Yeah, I was going to say it doesn't sound like Bill on bass, too crappy and all over the place. And yes, it sounds like the bass is leading everything.

Quote
deardoctor

Quote
alfstone
I always thought it´s Keith on bass

i don´t think so. bass playing is way too good. It also doesn´t sound like Ronnie (compare with fingerprint file)
All that slapping disco stuff - that´s surely bill.

Fingerprint File, you mean the song that Mick Taylor plays bass on?

[thepowergoats.com]



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2013-03-06 02:53 by jamesfdouglas.

Charlie on drums, Ian McLagan on wurly, Wood on bass and Keys on sax. According to McLagan it is a Wood penned song, not Jagger/Richards.

Mathijs

Quote
jamesfdouglas

Quote
deardoctor

Quote
alfstone
I always thought it´s Keith on bass

i don´t think so. bass playing is way too good. It also doesn´t sound like Ronnie (compare with fingerprint file)
All that slapping disco stuff - that´s surely bill.

Fingerprint File, you mean the song that Mick Taylor plays bass on?

LYL

Quote
Mathijs
Charlie on drums, Ian McLagan on wurly, Wood on bass and Keys on sax. According to McLagan it is a Wood penned song, not Jagger/Richards.

Mathijs

Sounds a bit sloppier than Ronnie's usual playing...

Quote
DandelionPowderman

Quote
jamesfdouglas

Quote
deardoctor

Quote
alfstone
I always thought it´s Keith on bass

i don´t think so. bass playing is way too good. It also doesn´t sound like Ronnie (compare with fingerprint file)
All that slapping disco stuff - that´s surely bill.

Fingerprint File, you mean the song that Mick Taylor plays bass on?

LYL

Oh, he did the studio version? I compared with the live 1975 versions that ronnie played.
Please compare the interludes on the high strings (that funky disco-stuff) with the bassline of Miss you. I think it´s the mostly underrated bill.

Sounds like Ronnie on bass. Compare to ER.

And yes it also sound a little like little T&A

Quote
DandelionPowderman
It' Keith all right...

Nope this is Ronnie

Quote
Redhotcarpet

Quote
DandelionPowderman
It' Keith all right...

Nope this is Ronnie

Nope it's Don

Quote
Mathijs
Charlie on drums, Ian McLagan on wurly, Wood on bass and Keys on sax. According to McLagan it is a Wood penned song, not Jagger/Richards.

Mathijs

In that combination it is more likely to be a song intended for Ian McLagan's Little Troublemaker than a Stones outtake?!