More gasoline on the LZ bonfire : wtf is this song named "Hot Dog"???? ><

The Stones would have never put such a trash on a disc!

The Stairway tribute by Heart and Jason Bonham was awesome. The reaction from Robert Plant and the rest of the band was moving. One of the great moments of rock in 2012. But still not the greatest rock band. We know who that is.

Quote
Laughingsam
1 - Stones fans aren't as rabidly insecure as Zeppelin fans

and how long have you participated on this board again??

Quote
dcba
More gasoline on the LZ bonfire : wtf is this song named "Hot Dog"???? ><

The Stones would have never put such a trash on a disc!

Ladies and Gentlemen I give you 'short an curlies'.

and what exactly does that mean?

Quote
dcba
More gasoline on the LZ bonfire : wtf is this song named "Hot Dog"???? ><

It's a tune I relish.... BEST ZEPPELIN SONG EVER!!!

Quote
dcba
More gasoline on the LZ bonfire : wtf is this song named "Hot Dog"???? ><

The Stones would have never put such a trash on a disc!

Works for me!

Yeah, the Stones would never do a tongue-in-cheek psuedo-country song.

And a 1 2 3--------4 Bonham's playing does not stand the test of time..



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2012-12-31 07:16 by DoomandGloom.

Quote
loog droog

Quote
dcba
More gasoline on the LZ bonfire : wtf is this song named "Hot Dog"???? ><

It's a tune I relish.... BEST ZEPPELIN SONG EVER!!!

Relish? I prefer mustard and onions on my Hot Dog
...go Jimmy go!

Quote
treaclefingers

Quote
dcba
More gasoline on the LZ bonfire : wtf is this song named "Hot Dog"???? ><

The Stones would have never put such a trash on a disc!

Ladies and Gentlemen I give you 'short an curlies'.

Objection overruled (by me)

Hold on...Led Zep had made more of a lasting impact in the few years they were together than any other band except maybe the Stones and the Beatles.

I can't see another 3 piece format with as much magic as those guys had. Just incredible. Although I heard it later, that first record released in the 60's set the standard for hard rock up several notches.

Zep will remain a huge force in what is left of Rock music, they influenced me deeply and continue to influence the kids who are playing rock these days. My hat is off to those fellows and the joy they have given me. No sense trying to cut them down or compare them to other acts, they were their own thing.

If you doubt their popularity or influence just check out the number of YouTube hits they have, more than the Stones or the Beatles. peace

Quote
Naturalust

If you doubt their popularity or influence just check out the number of YouTube hits they have, more than the Stones or the Beatles. peace

Gangnam Style has even more YT hits...

Quote
dcba

Quote
Naturalust

If you doubt their popularity or influence just check out the number of YouTube hits they have, more than the Stones or the Beatles. peace

Gangnam Style has even more YT hits...

whoop, whoop, whoop

Was just watching "The Muppets" the other day, and everybody's favorite Zeppelin fan was in the movie. I couldn't help but think of this thread. Jack Black is tied up on stage with the Muppets and their little barber shop quartet did a version of "Smells Like Teen Spirit" and Jack said they were ruining "one of the greatest songs of all time", and I figured people here would have something to say about that too.

I can't help but think that line was added on account of Dave Grohl making a cameo in a Muppet rip-off band in Reno, in which he played drums dressed like Animal.



Fun movie though. Took me back to my youth.

Led Zep made some great albums and I don't wanna compare!
Jimmy Page "Yardbirds" formed the New Yardbirds in 1968 and in the end of 1968
Led Zeppelin was formed after Keith Moons discription of a bad performance;
"Goin down like a led zeppelin".
The Roots of Led Zeppelin cd;
1.Little Richard-Long Tall Sally
2.Garnet Mimms-As long as I have you
3.Robert Johnson-Travelling Riverside Blues
4.Bukka White-Shake'em down
5.Santa & Johnny-Summertime
6.Bert Jansch-Blackwater side
7.John Rebourn-Nobody's Fault but mine
8.Spirit-Fresh Garbage
9.Muddy Waters-You need love
10.Howlin Wolf-Killing Floor
11.Blind Willie Johnson-In my time of dying
12.Davey Graham-She moved thru the bizarre/blue ragga
13.Joan Baez-Baby I'm gonna leave you
14.John Fahey-Dance of the inhabitants of the palace of King Phillip X1V of Spain
15.Owen Hand-She like it.

Quote
jamesfdouglas

Quote
Wild Slivovitz

Quote
DoomandGloom
Robert Plant on his best day couldn't wipe Mick's butt.

+1
I couldn't have said it any better!

Well... good luck with that.



(f'ing idiots)

So what's your point? Please keep your insults for yourself.

Quote
Naturalust
Hold on...Led Zep had made more of a lasting impact in the few years they were together than any other band except maybe the Stones and the Beatles.

I can't see another 3 piece format with as much magic as those guys had. Just incredible. Although I heard it later, that first record released in the 60's set the standard for hard rock up several notches.

Zep will remain a huge force in what is left of Rock music, they influenced me deeply and continue to influence the kids who are playing rock these days. My hat is off to those fellows and the joy they have given me. No sense trying to cut them down or compare them to other acts, they were their own thing.

If you doubt their popularity or influence just check out the number of YouTube hits they have, more than the Stones or the Beatles. peace

Well said:

No sense trying to cut them down or compare them to other acts, they were their own thing.

I loved it, but then I read later that Mr. Black said the same thing when The Who were being honored, so... he's free with the praise. What are you gonna do.

I think "Hot Dog" is a cool fun song.

Quote
Elmo Lewis
I think "Hot Dog" is a cool fun song.

I like 'Hotdog' too, (& 'Old King' on Neil Young's Harvest moon) but who the hell is Jack Black?...(still don't know even having seen his mug & gut on page 1)...I know I'll have to google him..........



Edited 3 time(s). Last edit at 2013-01-03 20:35 by EddieByword.

Quote
Beast of Babylon
The moment jack black said at the Kennedy Center Honors, they were "the greatest rock band in history....better than the beatles and better than the stones".....i turned it off, and threw up in my mouth a little bit. Comparing the beatles and stones to Zepplin is like comparing ice cream to horse manure.....the beatles changed how music was played, recorded, distributed, written and its culture impact. The stones did almost the same thing, but in a different way....by mastering a sound and testing and succeeding in every genre, rock, blues, country, funk, disco and punk. they also created and recreated and recreated and recreated what a live concert should be.

to me, putting them in the same post, let alone sentence is just plain wrong

That says it all

Quote
Elmo Lewis
I think "Hot Dog" is a cool fun song.

It is, but I wonder what Page was thinking in letting that guitar solo on - it rivals George Harrison's "All You Need is Love" solo in lameness.

I wonder if it was Pagey's comment on (some) people criticizing his technique as sloppy.

I think Jack Black was there because he's a huge Zeppelin fan so you would expect him to say they are the greatest ever just as we Stones fans say The Stones are the greatest ever- even though public opinion would say it's The Beatles.

I think if you were to poll 100 rock and roll historians/critics etc. The Beatles and Stones would finish one/two as far as the greatest bands of all time. The big question is who would be three? Zeppelin? The Who? U2? The Beach Boys?

Quote
dcba
More gasoline on the LZ bonfire : wtf is this song named "Hot Dog"???? ><

The Stones would have never put such a trash on a disc!

You've never heard Start Me up?

Quote
FrankM
I think if you were to poll 100 rock and roll historians/critics etc. The Beatles and Stones would finish one/two as far as the greatest bands of all time. The big question is who would be three? Zeppelin? The Who? U2? The Beach Boys?

that's a smaller question than this one, though:

who gives a flying fukk!!!???

Quote
sweetcharmedlife

Quote
dcba
More gasoline on the LZ bonfire : wtf is this song named "Hot Dog"???? ><

The Stones would have never put such a trash on a disc!

You've never heard Start Me up?

You're comparing Hot Dog to Start Me Up? That's like comparing an AMC Gremlin to a Jaguar.

Quote
FrankM

Quote
sweetcharmedlife

Quote
dcba
More gasoline on the LZ bonfire : wtf is this song named "Hot Dog"???? ><

The Stones would have never put such a trash on a disc!

You've never heard Start Me up?

You're comparing Hot Dog to Start Me Up? That's like comparing an AMC Gremlin to a Jaguar.

Start me up a Jaguar? More like a pinto.A piece of shit.

Quote
Wild Slivovitz

Quote
jamesfdouglas

Quote
Wild Slivovitz

Quote
DoomandGloom
Robert Plant on his best day couldn't wipe Mick's butt.

+1
I couldn't have said it any better!

Well... good luck with that.



(f'ing idiots)

So what's your point? Please keep your insults for yourself.

Um, you're the one insulting Robert Plant.
Either way, you can keep telling me how to post here. And I'll offer you a nice, tall glass of f--- off.

[thepowergoats.com]

Quote
jamesfdouglas
And I'll offer you a nice, tall glass of f--- off.

is that stuff available in convenient, carry-out four-packs yet?