Hi all!
There's been talk before of a live album from this tour coming out. I was just wondering if there is any insider info, or if this is all speculation. If there is insider info... spill the beans!

Me know nuffin' …..



ROCKMAN

I'll bet you could play Tumblin' Dice from any concert since 2005 and you wouldn't be able to tell the difference. Unless it was some kind of rarities collection, why would you possibly ever need a Rolling Stones live album, again? It's not like anything changes. Same backup musicians. Same everything. Tours used to be distinctive. That ended after No Security.

useless

I for one would be very pleased to see a No Filter live album .

I get it that folks think it would be the same as every other live release covering shows from the last 25 years or so ...but I love all the subtle little differences in arrangements from one tour to the next.

Normally I think we would see such a release quite soon...but after all the waiting for the studio album , even they might not have the hard faced cheek to take the easy live album option as the next release at this time.

[Then again...maybe they would...and it would buy them more time ]

No Filter Rarities Live woud be great

Quote
1962
No Filter Rarities Live woud be great

Yes it would !

not only useless but also unlikely since they've just release live stuff from the No Filter tour on the Honk compilation

We just got some live tracks on Honk, but I'm definitely up for that.

Quote
1962
No Filter Rarities Live woud be great

Pardon, what rarities? Suggest a songlist, please.

Quote
saltoftheearth

Quote
1962
No Filter Rarities Live woud be great

Pardon, what rarities? Suggest a songlist, please.

Here it is:

Dancing With Mr D
Play With Fire (accoustic)
Just Your Fool
She's A Rainbow
Hate To See You Go
Con Le Mie Lacrime
Rocks Off
Under My Thumb
Shine A Light
Heartbreaker
Get Off Of My Clud
Sweet Virginia (accoustic)
Dead Flowers (accoustic)
She's So Cold
Neighbours
The Worst
Fool To Cry
Like A Rolling Stone
You Got The Silver
Shattered
Beast Of Burden
Sad Sad Sad
Monkey Man
Mercy Mercy
Let It Bleed (accoustic)
Angie (accoustic)

Quote
1962

Quote
saltoftheearth

Quote
1962
No Filter Rarities Live woud be great

Pardon, what rarities? Suggest a songlist, please.

Here it is:

Dancing With Mr D
Play With Fire (accoustic)
Just Your Fool
She's A Rainbow
Hate To See You Go
Con Le Mie Lacrime
Rocks Off
Under My Thumb
Shine A Light
Heartbreaker
Get Off Of My Clud
Sweet Virginia (accoustic)
Dead Flowers (accoustic)
She's So Cold
Neighbours
The Worst
Fool To Cry
Like A Rolling Stone
You Got The Silver
Shattered
Beast Of Burden
Sad Sad Sad
Monkey Man
Mercy Mercy
Let It Bleed (accoustic)
Angie (accoustic)

Would be great. Three of those are already on Honk, though.

Quote
24FPS
I'll bet you could play Tumblin' Dice from any concert since 2005 and you wouldn't be able to tell the difference. Unless it was some kind of rarities collection, why would you possibly ever need a Rolling Stones live album, again? It's not like anything changes. Same backup musicians. Same everything. Tours used to be distinctive. That ended after No Security.

One very noticeable difference would be no more Lisa Fisher singing Merry Clayton's vocals on Gimmie Shelter where since 2015 it has been Sasha . Tell me you can't tell a difference from Lisa Fisher ?

These days even the rarities are tried and tested.

Quote
TheGreek

Quote
24FPS
I'll bet you could play Tumblin' Dice from any concert since 2005 and you wouldn't be able to tell the difference. Unless it was some kind of rarities collection, why would you possibly ever need a Rolling Stones live album, again? It's not like anything changes. Same backup musicians. Same everything. Tours used to be distinctive. That ended after No Security.

One very noticeable difference would be no more Lisa Fisher singing Merry Clayton's vocals on Gimmie Shelter where since 2015 it has been Sasha . Tell me you can't tell a difference from Lisa Fisher ?

Is it really audibly different? How?

HONK is lame for so many reasons, and a few live tracks don't elevate it at all.
They need to release an entire NoFilter set on album, cd, and dvd, otherwise the poor casual fans who bought HONK might get the wrong impression of the Stones.
In other words, just like they can't put together a new album of originals, they can't even bother to release an entire show's worth of material.
Is it a greatest hits? A random compilation? A live release? It's all of the above which dilutes everything about it.
Release a proper live album at least, which would somewhat fill the void of not being capable of finishing/releasing a new studio album of originals.

_____________________________________________________________
Rip this joint, gonna save your soul, round and round and round we go......



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2019-07-25 19:41 by Hairball.

That one has to be on it:
Mercy Mercy : super rarely played, marking an unspoken event and part of a spectacular show in Maryland,USA.
Rockandroll,
Mops

Some time ago they played Silver Train (with Mick Taylor).
It should be on it too.
Rockandroll,
Mops

The void? Yes, we are all really thirsty for another Stones live album from 2019...Sweet summer sun and Cuba wasn´t enoguh...We MUST have thirteen thousand versions of the set that has been going on since 2015...2014...1989...

Stones has - like NO other band - wasted their career. So many posibilities, so many songs - so many ways they could have created new and exciting formulas.

She smiled sweetly could be a wonderful song to end a concert with. Keith could sing song number 6 and eleven. A theme for each tour. They could rearrange some songs, and a thousand other things, play around with the whole concept, what a concert can be like.

But. No.

Quote
24FPS

Quote
TheGreek

Quote
24FPS
I'll bet you could play Tumblin' Dice from any concert since 2005 and you wouldn't be able to tell the difference. Unless it was some kind of rarities collection, why would you possibly ever need a Rolling Stones live album, again? It's not like anything changes. Same backup musicians. Same everything. Tours used to be distinctive. That ended after No Security.

One very noticeable difference would be no more Lisa Fisher singing Merry Clayton's vocals on Gimmie Shelter where since 2015 it has been Sasha . Tell me you can't tell a difference from Lisa Fisher ?

Is it really audibly different? How?

You can't tell the difference from Lisa to Sasha ? Really ?

Quote
Rockman
Me know nuffin' …..

Yes you do all humble one

Quote
Hairball
HONK is lame for so many reasons, and a few live tracks don't elevate it at all.

While your point is valid, there are actually ten live tracks on the third disc. That is a live album, not an EP. At this point we already have SWEET SUMMER SUN and HAVANA MOON on CD with very nearly the same setlist. The only difference is Lisa vs. Sasha, Bobby vs. Karl, and a Mick Taylor guest spot. Ten live rarities as a compilation (there I said it) of live tracks since 2012 isn't a bad way to go. Otherwise it's third time to the well with the same set list.

I would welcome a No Security II cd.

Quote
Bjorn
The void? Yes, we are all really thirsty for another Stones live album from 2019...Sweet summer sun and Cuba wasn´t enoguh...We MUST have thirteen thousand versions of the set that has been going on since 2015...2014...1989...

Stones has - like NO other band - wasted their career. So many posibilities, so many songs - so many ways they could have created new and exciting formulas.

She smiled sweetly could be a wonderful song to end a concert with. Keith could sing song number 6 and eleven. A theme for each tour. They could rearrange some songs, and a thousand other things, play around with the whole concept, what a concert can be like.

But. No.

Their monomaniacal focus on such a narrow band of their oeuvre, while understandable is nevertheless remarkable. Their unwavering devotion to and focus on particular arrangements of particular songs bespeaks a discipline which is even more impressive than the fact that they are still doing what they do at their ages.

How can they play almost the exact same songs in exactly the same way for decades? It's really a herculean achievement.

NS 2!!!! Yes!!!
Intro to b-stage Queenie Crazy mamá
Lowdown Already over me Might as well get juiced Time Is on my side Like a Rolling stone 11-04-98 How can i stop Shame shame shame Love Is strong 19th NB Star star

Jajaja what an álbum!!

Quote
24FPS
I'll bet you could play Tumblin' Dice from any concert since 2005 and you wouldn't be able to tell the difference. Unless it was some kind of rarities collection, why would you possibly ever need a Rolling Stones live album, again? It's not like anything changes. Same backup musicians. Same everything. Tours used to be distinctive. That ended after No Security.

What about Street Fightin' Man or Monk' Man? Midnite Ramble? Jumping Jack Flash?
It's Only Rock'N'Roll (But I Likes It)?

Quote
LazarusSmith
Their monomaniacal focus on such a narrow band of their oeuvre, while understandable is nevertheless remarkable. Their unwavering devotion to and focus on particular arrangements of particular songs bespeaks a discipline which is even more impressive than the fact that they are still doing what they do at their ages.

How can they play almost the exact same songs in exactly the same way for decades? It's really a herculean achievement.

I really hope that is sarcasm, otherwise I'd like to introduce you to Mike Love and company. You'll be even more astounded.

Quote
GasLightStreet

Quote
24FPS
I'll bet you could play Tumblin' Dice from any concert since 2005 and you wouldn't be able to tell the difference. Unless it was some kind of rarities collection, why would you possibly ever need a Rolling Stones live album, again? It's not like anything changes. Same backup musicians. Same everything. Tours used to be distinctive. That ended after No Security.

What about Street Fightin' Man or Monk' Man? Midnite Ramble? Jumping Jack Flash?
It's Only Rock'N'Roll (But I Likes It)?

Yes, those would sound the same too. Tumblin' Dice was just used as an example. Even the 'rarities' have turned into warhorses. No other band has such an exciting catalogue with such depth to draw from. It truly is a disappoint to the seasoned fan. Their concerts are for the casual fan with money to burn. Their songs have lost all resonance. It's a nostalgia trip. Bill saw it coming.

Quote
Rocky Dijon

Quote
LazarusSmith
Their monomaniacal focus on such a narrow band of their oeuvre, while understandable is nevertheless remarkable. Their unwavering devotion to and focus on particular arrangements of particular songs bespeaks a discipline which is even more impressive than the fact that they are still doing what they do at their ages.

How can they play almost the exact same songs in exactly the same way for decades? It's really a herculean achievement.

I really hope that is sarcasm, otherwise I'd like to introduce you to Mike Love and company. You'll be even more astounded.

And after that put on YCAGWYW-versions between 2012 and today, to spot different changes to the song and its arrangement



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2019-07-26 09:21 by DandelionPowderman.

Quote
24FPS

Quote
GasLightStreet

Quote
24FPS
I'll bet you could play Tumblin' Dice from any concert since 2005 and you wouldn't be able to tell the difference. Unless it was some kind of rarities collection, why would you possibly ever need a Rolling Stones live album, again? It's not like anything changes. Same backup musicians. Same everything. Tours used to be distinctive. That ended after No Security.

What about Street Fightin' Man or Monk' Man? Midnite Ramble? Jumping Jack Flash?
It's Only Rock'N'Roll (But I Likes It)?

Yes, those would sound the same too. Tumblin' Dice was just used as an example. Even the 'rarities' have turned into warhorses. No other band has such an exciting catalogue with such depth to draw from. It truly is a disappoint to the seasoned fan. Their concerts are for the casual fan with money to burn. Their songs have lost all resonance. It's a nostalgia trip. Bill saw it coming.

You seriously belive Rambler and Street Fighting Man sound the same?

They started with merging other songs into MR in 2015 + they play it differently. The "did you hear about..."-part is also different now.

There is no sitar-sounds on SFM from Ronnie anymore, and Keith plays the main riff in a noticeable different way.

You don't hear these things, or you don't bother to check it out?