Love the 69 tour and the way they played UMT, esp. at Altamont.
Some 81 weren't bad as well. But Hampton to me is not one of the best.Even some from 97 tour- like the Dusseldorf version- weren't so bad.

This version in Austin, Texas is very good. It also shows that Keith can play a great solo. It is better than any other other version I have ever heard.

Quote
melillo
just because mick n keith rearranged it during the wood versions should not reflect on woody

The 81 version is the very same arrangement as they used in 1965 with Brian. Listen to the opening track on Got Live If You Want It.

and your point is?

Quote
flilflam




This version in Austin, Texas is very good. It also shows that Keith can play a great solo. It is better than any other other version I have ever heard.

Nice version for sure, but who's playing Keiths part when he clearly isn't playing the guitar? Or when he most clearly doesn't play what you hear.
I guess it's a studio fix/overdub.

[www.reverbnation.com]

Woody version rocks.......

Quote
Erik_Snow
Under My Thumb from Altamont 1969 is absolutely fantastic. The best version I know of that song

+1

Nobody for the fantastic Got Live version? That was the first time I ever heard the song. I still compare every version to that one. "Ladies and Gentlemen it's all about to happen...!"

I don't like any live version, be it with Brian, Taylor, Wood. The studio version is perfect.

the '85 version was too sloppy. Probably due to the fact that charlie was on junk.

Quote melillo
just because mick n keith rearranged it during the wood versions should not reflect on woody

Quote
melillo
and your point is?

It shouldn't reflect on Woody, as he only played a prior arranged version from 1965 in 1981.

Quote
Palace Revolution 2000
Nobody for the fantastic Got Live version? That was the first time I ever heard the song. I still compare every version to that one. "Ladies and Gentlemen it's all about to happen...!"

+ 1

Both Keith and Brian play solos on this version. Didn't happen too often.

Quote
DandelionPowderman

Quote
Palace Revolution 2000
Nobody for the fantastic Got Live version? That was the first time I ever heard the song. I still compare every version to that one. "Ladies and Gentlemen it's all about to happen...!"

+ 1

Both Keith and Brian play solos on this version. Didn't happen too often.

I think you are mistaken regarding Brian playing a solo on UMT.

Also, there's 2 live versions from UK 66 tour, one has overdubbed marimba in addition to the vocals etc.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2012-02-06 14:30 by His Majesty.

The studio version is mind blowing. That's how I got hooked.

Quote
flilflam




This version in Austin, Texas is very good. It also shows that Keith can play a great solo. It is better than any other other version I have ever heard.

First, it's not Keith, and second it is a terrible solo.

All guitars on this track are overdubbed by the guitar techs.

Mathijs

Quote
His Majesty

Quote
DandelionPowderman

Quote
Palace Revolution 2000
Nobody for the fantastic Got Live version? That was the first time I ever heard the song. I still compare every version to that one. "Ladies and Gentlemen it's all about to happen...!"

+ 1

Both Keith and Brian play solos on this version. Didn't happen too often.

I think you are mistaken regarding Brian playing a solo on UMT.

Also, there's 2 live versions from UK 66 tour, one has overdubbed marimba in addition to the vocals etc.

Well, on my copy of Have You Seen Your Mother LIVE, there clearly are two short solo breaks straight after eachother, and it sure sounds like both guitarists play.

However, it COULD be that Keith did an extra overdub in the studio, but the way it sounds I really doubt it. I'm gonna have one more listen, though.

Quote
DandelionPowderman


Well, on my copy of Have You Seen Your Mother LIVE, there clearly are two short solo breaks straight after eachother, and it sure sounds like both guitarists play.

However, it COULD be that Keith did an extra overdub in the studio, but the way it sounds I really doubt it. I'm gonna have one more listen, though.

Just so we are listening to the same version, does the one you have feature an overdubbed marimba?

If we go by what Bill has said about that album I think it's a certainty that Keith overdubbed guitar on some if not all of the tracks.

Quote
Mathijs

Quote
flilflam




This version in Austin, Texas is very good. It also shows that Keith can play a great solo. It is better than any other other version I have ever heard.

First, it's not Keith, and second it is a terrible solo.

All guitars on this track are overdubbed by the guitar techs.

Mathijs

Mathijs, who is playing?

Quote
The Joker

Quote
Mathijs

Quote
flilflam




This version in Austin, Texas is very good. It also shows that Keith can play a great solo. It is better than any other other version I have ever heard.

First, it's not Keith, and second it is a terrible solo.

All guitars on this track are overdubbed by the guitar techs.

Mathijs

Mathijs, who is playing?

"Additional recordings by Pierre DeBeauport and Dave Rouze". It's in the liner notes.

Quote
His Majesty

Quote
DandelionPowderman


Well, on my copy of Have You Seen Your Mother LIVE, there clearly are two short solo breaks straight after eachother, and it sure sounds like both guitarists play.

However, it COULD be that Keith did an extra overdub in the studio, but the way it sounds I really doubt it. I'm gonna have one more listen, though.

Just so we are listening to the same version, does the one you have feature an overdubbed marimba?

If we go by what Bill has said about that album I think it's a certainty that Keith overdubbed guitar on some if not all of the tracks.

No marimba Only the guitars playing the riff. Some humming from Mick in the beginning.

Quote
DandelionPowderman
"Additional recordings by Pierre DeBeauport and Dave Rouze".

pierre and dave have perfected the weave

Quote
StonesTod

Quote
DandelionPowderman
"Additional recordings by Pierre DeBeauport and Dave Rouze".

pierre and dave have perfected the weave

They're more into crocheting, if you ask me (which you didn't)

Quote
DandelionPowderman

Quote
His Majesty

Quote
DandelionPowderman


Well, on my copy of Have You Seen Your Mother LIVE, there clearly are two short solo breaks straight after eachother, and it sure sounds like both guitarists play.

However, it COULD be that Keith did an extra overdub in the studio, but the way it sounds I really doubt it. I'm gonna have one more listen, though.

Just so we are listening to the same version, does the one you have feature an overdubbed marimba?

If we go by what Bill has said about that album I think it's a certainty that Keith overdubbed guitar on some if not all of the tracks.

No marimba Only the guitars playing the riff. Some humming from Mick in the beginning.

Mix of original recording and overdubs. There's another version in which the high notes are missing, but the other main guitar is the same.

So that makes 3different versions using same basic recording.

Quote
His Majesty

Quote
DandelionPowderman

Quote
His Majesty

Quote
DandelionPowderman


Well, on my copy of Have You Seen Your Mother LIVE, there clearly are two short solo breaks straight after eachother, and it sure sounds like both guitarists play.

However, it COULD be that Keith did an extra overdub in the studio, but the way it sounds I really doubt it. I'm gonna have one more listen, though.

Just so we are listening to the same version, does the one you have feature an overdubbed marimba?

If we go by what Bill has said about that album I think it's a certainty that Keith overdubbed guitar on some if not all of the tracks.

No marimba Only the guitars playing the riff. Some humming from Mick in the beginning.

Mix of original recording and overdubs. There's another version in which the high notes are missing, but the other main guitar is the same.

So that makes 3different versions using same basic recording.

So, the conclusion is overdub by Keith? Darn, can't we at least have one well-documented Brian solo that's not slide? I thought I had one there

Quote
DandelionPowderman

Quote
His Majesty

Quote
DandelionPowderman

Quote
His Majesty

Quote
DandelionPowderman


Well, on my copy of Have You Seen Your Mother LIVE, there clearly are two short solo breaks straight after eachother, and it sure sounds like both guitarists play.

However, it COULD be that Keith did an extra overdub in the studio, but the way it sounds I really doubt it. I'm gonna have one more listen, though.

Just so we are listening to the same version, does the one you have feature an overdubbed marimba?

If we go by what Bill has said about that album I think it's a certainty that Keith overdubbed guitar on some if not all of the tracks.

No marimba Only the guitars playing the riff. Some humming from Mick in the beginning.

Mix of original recording and overdubs. There's another version in which the high notes are missing, but the other main guitar is the same.

So that makes 3different versions using same basic recording.

So, the conclusion is overdub by Keith? Darn, can't we at least have one well-documented Brian solo that's not slide? I thought I had one there

What about the credits? Who is paid for what? Must be a little fussy.

I remember hearing UMT during the 11/8/69, 2nd show. The show started well after midnight, there was a fatigue factor and there was what seemed like a long stretch of low key songs. The nice, gentle groove introduction to UMT was welcomed and a signaled a change of pace in the show. The performance of that song perked me up.

1. Studio
2. Altamont
3. 1981

Quote
DandelionPowderman

Quote
The Joker

Quote
Mathijs

Quote
flilflam




This version in Austin, Texas is very good. It also shows that Keith can play a great solo. It is better than any other other version I have ever heard.

First, it's not Keith, and second it is a terrible solo.

All guitars on this track are overdubbed by the guitar techs.

Mathijs

Mathijs, who is playing?

"Additional recordings by Pierre DeBeauport and Dave Rouze". It's in the liner notes.

Indeed. I wasn't aware WHo it was w/ the overdubs, but that is wild - absolutely not Keith solo-ing. At first the solo has the Strat sound, that up till then had been Ronnie, and then a dirtier sound comes in, but it is obvious from the left hand that it is not Keith playing.

MSG 28/11/69 (1st)

My all time favorite, very similar to Altamont but it includes I´m Free (which is cut here unfortunately): great tempo and a killer Keith guitar solo...

Quote
The Joker

Quote
DandelionPowderman

Quote
His Majesty

Quote
DandelionPowderman

Quote
His Majesty

Quote
DandelionPowderman


Well, on my copy of Have You Seen Your Mother LIVE, there clearly are two short solo breaks straight after eachother, and it sure sounds like both guitarists play.

However, it COULD be that Keith did an extra overdub in the studio, but the way it sounds I really doubt it. I'm gonna have one more listen, though.

Just so we are listening to the same version, does the one you have feature an overdubbed marimba?

If we go by what Bill has said about that album I think it's a certainty that Keith overdubbed guitar on some if not all of the tracks.

No marimba Only the guitars playing the riff. Some humming from Mick in the beginning.

Mix of original recording and overdubs. There's another version in which the high notes are missing, but the other main guitar is the same.

So that makes 3different versions using same basic recording.

So, the conclusion is overdub by Keith? Darn, can't we at least have one well-documented Brian solo that's not slide? I thought I had one there

What about the credits? Who is paid for what? Must be a little fussy.

While not a solo, but today I was listening to the Stones "Roll Over Beethoven" recording. And it is another one of the older recordings by them where we can really hear the dual guitars. Brian is very prominent.
I have to say my favorite Brian guitar is "Confessin the Blues".