For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
shortfatfanny
Good idea...kick Ronnie,Darryl and the rest of the stage musicians out,take Bill and Taylor back...forget the last 49 years and case closed.
Easy...isn't it ?
Did I or you miss something ?
Quote
stonehearted
It would've been great if in '69 they could've played em like on Rolling Stones Now!
Too have a full, rich recorded live document of those first three albums would have been perfect.
Those early live recordings don't do their early performances justice.
But alas, by '69, they could no longer play like they did in '65.
Quote
pmk251
That band no longer exists. But it left one of the most compelling and enduring examples of recorded RnR music ever. Ya-Ya's never lets me down even after all these years. It is even better now that you can assemble a complete show from the deluxe edition's extra tracks.
Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
stonehearted
It would've been great if in '69 they could've played em like on Rolling Stones Now!
Too have a full, rich recorded live document of those first three albums would have been perfect.
Those early live recordings don't do their early performances justice.
But alas, by '69, they could no longer play like they did in '65.
On Air was a pretty good document?
Quote
stoneheartedQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
stonehearted
It would've been great if in '69 they could've played em like on Rolling Stones Now!
Too have a full, rich recorded live document of those first three albums would have been perfect.
Those early live recordings don't do their early performances justice.
But alas, by '69, they could no longer play like they did in '65.
On Air was a pretty good document?
But Ya Yas was in stereo.
Quote
BungoQuote
shortfatfanny
Good idea...kick Ronnie,Darryl and the rest of the stage musicians out,take Bill and Taylor back...forget the last 49 years and case closed.
Easy...isn't it ?
Did I or you miss something ?
Yeah. You definitely missed it. I'm not suggesting changing out any key players. I'm talking about the arrangements, specifically the guitar parts. They perfected the live versions of a lot of these songs back in '69 and '72 yet they act like that never even happened. These new versions sound like they were arranged by a high school garage band. Absolutely dreadful.
Quote
shortfatfanny
Good idea...kick Ronnie,Darryl and the rest of the stage musicians out,take Bill and Taylor back...forget the last 49 years and case closed.
Easy...isn't it ?
Did I or you miss something ?
Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
stoneheartedQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
stonehearted
It would've been great if in '69 they could've played em like on Rolling Stones Now!
Too have a full, rich recorded live document of those first three albums would have been perfect.
Those early live recordings don't do their early performances justice.
But alas, by '69, they could no longer play like they did in '65.
On Air was a pretty good document?
But Ya Yas was in stereo.
The Camden-tracks, too
Quote
stoneheartedQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
stoneheartedQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
stonehearted
It would've been great if in '69 they could've played em like on Rolling Stones Now!
Too have a full, rich recorded live document of those first three albums would have been perfect.
Those early live recordings don't do their early performances justice.
But alas, by '69, they could no longer play like they did in '65.
On Air was a pretty good document?
But Ya Yas was in stereo.
The Camden-tracks, too
Yes, all four of them.
Be that as it may, the whole point of my post was to highlight that in '69 they could no longer play in the same way as they did around '65.
Quote
Bungo
I was watching the Sweet Summer Sun / Hyde Park show the other day and it struck me how retarded a song like Sympathy For The Devil has become over the years compared to the amazing versions heard on Get Yer Ya Yas Out. Why don't they just play it like that? 2 guitars, drums and bass. And the guitar lines they play in these current versions are just childish and un-musical compared to the perfect simple guitar lines on Ya Yas. I just don't get it. Do they not know how good they sounded on the '69 and '72 tours? Can they not remember those classic, simple guitar lines? I can't believe they're physically or mentally incapable of playing these songs properly. The guitar parts on Ya Yas are not that damn complicated. Any reasonably competent guitar player can replicate those versions, which are the best versions they've ever played "live". I just don't f@@king get it. I quit. I'm out.
Quote
GasLightStreet
It started, obviously, in 1989 with SFTD because Mick wanted them to sound like the records. Here's Keith with that as well:
Over the years, you develop a simplified road version of a song that you get used to. But this time, we thought, Let's go back and listen very carefully to the records to find what we were originally going for when we made it. All the subtleties and the half bar jumps. We thought we ought to do the songs up proud and have the things that were on the record. And once you go back and research what you did, you say, Well, the reason we did it like that is because we had these voices or because we had these horns. That's why we have the enlarged line-up. Tumbling Dice without the voices is kind of bare.
[timeisonourside.com]
Fortunately they completely changed SMU.