Quote
StonesTod

Quote
Erik_Snow

Quote
DandelionPowderman
The sound, for starters?

Yes, indeed, the sound

bollocks. if someone had told you this was stu on piano, everyone would be singing the praises of the mighty ian stewart. the fact is that chuck is a master of all styles...it's why stu picked him...chuck can do stu, nicky, billy...and just about anyone else....now, please stop the chuck bashing and let's back to our regularly scheduled ronnie and keith bashings....

No there's a big difference in sound. Compare Key To The Highway on Dirty Work with Fancyman Blues from 1989 for instance, for a prime example.

Quote
StonesTod

Quote
Munichhilton

Quote
StonesTod
disagree. chuck can boogie woogie as well as the next guy, including stu...ask stu yourself.

Hang on

I"M the next guy and I resent the implication...

the implication that ppl's criticisms about chuck are really just masks for their resentment in the rest of the band lacking in energy?

whoa

I'm out

Quote
Erik_Snow

Quote
StonesTod

Quote
Erik_Snow

Quote
DandelionPowderman
The sound, for starters?

Yes, indeed, the sound

bollocks. if someone had told you this was stu on piano, everyone would be singing the praises of the mighty ian stewart. the fact is that chuck is a master of all styles...it's why stu picked him...chuck can do stu, nicky, billy...and just about anyone else....now, please stop the chuck bashing and let's back to our regularly scheduled ronnie and keith bashings....

No there's a big difference in sound. Compare Key To The Highway on Dirty Work with Fancyman Blues from 1989 for instance, for a prime example.

the way the piano is recorded is your criticism now? i give up....

i understand your need to find a fall guy, erik...but there's not enough evidence to convict this guy...i ask the judge to throw the case out....

Quote
Munichhilton

Quote
StonesTod

Quote
Munichhilton

Quote
StonesTod
disagree. chuck can boogie woogie as well as the next guy, including stu...ask stu yourself.

Hang on

I"M the next guy and I resent the implication...

the implication that ppl's criticisms about chuck are really just masks for their resentment in the rest of the band lacking in energy?

whoa

I'm out

excellent. one down, one to go...

Quote
StonesTod

Quote
Erik_Snow

Quote
DandelionPowderman
The sound, for starters?

Yes, indeed, the sound

bollocks. if someone had told you this was stu on piano, everyone would be singing the praises of the mighty ian stewart. the fact is that chuck is a master of all styles...it's why stu picked him...chuck can do stu, nicky, billy...and just about anyone else....now, please stop the chuck bashing and let's back to our regularly scheduled ronnie and keith bashings....

Bollocks? You wondered what the difference between Chuck's casio keyboard and Stu's piano was. To my ears they sound very different.

But if you get a real piano listening experience while listening to Chuck's keyboard, good for you.

IMO, being a generalist, and to a degree master many styles (not being the master of all styles - Chuck) is not necessarily a better thing than being a specialist (Stu at boogie-woogie).

Can't help but to feel bad for starting all of this, why can't we all just get along?

Quote
StonesTod

Quote
Erik_Snow

Quote
StonesTod

Quote
Erik_Snow

Quote
DandelionPowderman
The sound, for starters?

Yes, indeed, the sound

bollocks. if someone had told you this was stu on piano, everyone would be singing the praises of the mighty ian stewart. the fact is that chuck is a master of all styles...it's why stu picked him...chuck can do stu, nicky, billy...and just about anyone else....now, please stop the chuck bashing and let's back to our regularly scheduled ronnie and keith bashings....

No there's a big difference in sound. Compare Key To The Highway on Dirty Work with Fancyman Blues from 1989 for instance, for a prime example.

the way the piano is recorded is your criticism now? i give up....

i understand your need to find a fall guy, erik...but there's not enough evidence to convict this guy...i ask the judge to throw the case out....

THat's not right - that I need to find a fall guy; I mean. We obviously have a different view on his playing; but you try to turn it into the standard "you just bash Chuck because of the fact that Rolling Stones themselves have declined" thingy. But that's not what I'm doing.

Strange if you don't hear any difference between classic piano sound and keyboard ala Fancyman Blues and So Young. Don't mean that you have to dismiss one sound and prefer the other - but strange if you don't hear any difference.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2011-11-25 16:31 by Erik_Snow.

Quote
shadooby
Can't help but to feel bad for starting all of this, why can't we all just get along?

who are you, the prodigal son or something?

it's cool - nobody's being serious here. it's black friday, after all...we're all just waiting in line for bargains...or something...

Quote
Erik_Snow

Quote
StonesTod

Quote
Erik_Snow

Quote
StonesTod

Quote
Erik_Snow

Quote
DandelionPowderman
The sound, for starters?

Yes, indeed, the sound

bollocks. if someone had told you this was stu on piano, everyone would be singing the praises of the mighty ian stewart. the fact is that chuck is a master of all styles...it's why stu picked him...chuck can do stu, nicky, billy...and just about anyone else....now, please stop the chuck bashing and let's back to our regularly scheduled ronnie and keith bashings....

No there's a big difference in sound. Compare Key To The Highway on Dirty Work with Fancyman Blues from 1989 for instance, for a prime example.

the way the piano is recorded is your criticism now? i give up....

i understand your need to find a fall guy, erik...but there's not enough evidence to convict this guy...i ask the judge to throw the case out....

THat's not right - that I need to find a fall guy; I mean. We obviously have a different view on his playing; but you try to turn it into the standard "you just bash Chuck because of the fact that Rolling Stones themselves have declined" thingy. But that's not what I'm doing.

Strange if you don't hear any difference between classic piano sound and keyboard ala Fancyman Blues and So Young. Don't mean that you have to dismiss one sound and prefer the other - but strange if you don't hear any difference.

listen, youngster. when you're as old as the hills like me, you'll find it strange you can hear anything at all.

Quote
StonesTod

Quote
Erik_Snow

Quote
StonesTod

Quote
Erik_Snow

Quote
StonesTod

Quote
Erik_Snow

Quote
DandelionPowderman
The sound, for starters?

Yes, indeed, the sound

bollocks. if someone had told you this was stu on piano, everyone would be singing the praises of the mighty ian stewart. the fact is that chuck is a master of all styles...it's why stu picked him...chuck can do stu, nicky, billy...and just about anyone else....now, please stop the chuck bashing and let's back to our regularly scheduled ronnie and keith bashings....

No there's a big difference in sound. Compare Key To The Highway on Dirty Work with Fancyman Blues from 1989 for instance, for a prime example.

the way the piano is recorded is your criticism now? i give up....

i understand your need to find a fall guy, erik...but there's not enough evidence to convict this guy...i ask the judge to throw the case out....

THat's not right - that I need to find a fall guy; I mean. We obviously have a different view on his playing; but you try to turn it into the standard "you just bash Chuck because of the fact that Rolling Stones themselves have declined" thingy. But that's not what I'm doing.

Strange if you don't hear any difference between classic piano sound and keyboard ala Fancyman Blues and So Young. Don't mean that you have to dismiss one sound and prefer the other - but strange if you don't hear any difference.

listen, youngster. when you're as old as the hills like me, you'll find it strange you can hear anything at all.

Thanks, I thought I was older than you. "Youngster"? Yep, got a nice ring to it!

Quote
DandelionPowderman

Quote
StonesTod

Quote
Erik_Snow

Quote
StonesTod

Quote
Erik_Snow

Quote
StonesTod

Quote
Erik_Snow

Quote
DandelionPowderman
The sound, for starters?

Yes, indeed, the sound

bollocks. if someone had told you this was stu on piano, everyone would be singing the praises of the mighty ian stewart. the fact is that chuck is a master of all styles...it's why stu picked him...chuck can do stu, nicky, billy...and just about anyone else....now, please stop the chuck bashing and let's back to our regularly scheduled ronnie and keith bashings....

No there's a big difference in sound. Compare Key To The Highway on Dirty Work with Fancyman Blues from 1989 for instance, for a prime example.

the way the piano is recorded is your criticism now? i give up....

i understand your need to find a fall guy, erik...but there's not enough evidence to convict this guy...i ask the judge to throw the case out....

THat's not right - that I need to find a fall guy; I mean. We obviously have a different view on his playing; but you try to turn it into the standard "you just bash Chuck because of the fact that Rolling Stones themselves have declined" thingy. But that's not what I'm doing.

Strange if you don't hear any difference between classic piano sound and keyboard ala Fancyman Blues and So Young. Don't mean that you have to dismiss one sound and prefer the other - but strange if you don't hear any difference.

listen, youngster. when you're as old as the hills like me, you'll find it strange you can hear anything at all.

Thanks, I thought I was older than you. "Youngster"? Yep, got a nice ring to it!

you may be, but erik ain't. i'm 74...or something like that...

Quote
StonesTod

Quote
Erik_Snow

Quote
StonesTod

Quote
Erik_Snow

Quote
StonesTod

Quote
Erik_Snow

Quote
DandelionPowderman
The sound, for starters?

Yes, indeed, the sound

bollocks. if someone had told you this was stu on piano, everyone would be singing the praises of the mighty ian stewart. the fact is that chuck is a master of all styles...it's why stu picked him...chuck can do stu, nicky, billy...and just about anyone else....now, please stop the chuck bashing and let's back to our regularly scheduled ronnie and keith bashings....

No there's a big difference in sound. Compare Key To The Highway on Dirty Work with Fancyman Blues from 1989 for instance, for a prime example.

the way the piano is recorded is your criticism now? i give up....

i understand your need to find a fall guy, erik...but there's not enough evidence to convict this guy...i ask the judge to throw the case out....

THat's not right - that I need to find a fall guy; I mean. We obviously have a different view on his playing; but you try to turn it into the standard "you just bash Chuck because of the fact that Rolling Stones themselves have declined" thingy. But that's not what I'm doing.

Strange if you don't hear any difference between classic piano sound and keyboard ala Fancyman Blues and So Young. Don't mean that you have to dismiss one sound and prefer the other - but strange if you don't hear any difference.

listen, youngster. when you're as old as the hills like me, you'll find it strange you can hear anything at all.

You are older than me? I thought you simply were taller

Quote
StonesTod

you may be, but erik ain't. i'm 74...or something like that...

What a letdown

There are SO Many hills older than that

Quote
Munichhilton

Quote
StonesTod

you may be, but erik ain't. i'm 74...or something like that...

What a letdown

There are SO Many hills older than that

in texas?

Quote
StonesTod

Quote
Munichhilton

Quote
StonesTod

you may be, but erik ain't. i'm 74...or something like that...

What a letdown

There are SO Many hills older than that

in texas?

Well....damn.
I'm out again

wait do ledges or precipices count?

Quote
Erik_Snow

Quote
StonesTod

Quote
Erik_Snow

Quote
StonesTod

Quote
Erik_Snow

Quote
StonesTod

Quote
Erik_Snow

Quote
DandelionPowderman
The sound, for starters?

Yes, indeed, the sound

bollocks. if someone had told you this was stu on piano, everyone would be singing the praises of the mighty ian stewart. the fact is that chuck is a master of all styles...it's why stu picked him...chuck can do stu, nicky, billy...and just about anyone else....now, please stop the chuck bashing and let's back to our regularly scheduled ronnie and keith bashings....

No there's a big difference in sound. Compare Key To The Highway on Dirty Work with Fancyman Blues from 1989 for instance, for a prime example.

the way the piano is recorded is your criticism now? i give up....

i understand your need to find a fall guy, erik...but there's not enough evidence to convict this guy...i ask the judge to throw the case out....

THat's not right - that I need to find a fall guy; I mean. We obviously have a different view on his playing; but you try to turn it into the standard "you just bash Chuck because of the fact that Rolling Stones themselves have declined" thingy. But that's not what I'm doing.

Strange if you don't hear any difference between classic piano sound and keyboard ala Fancyman Blues and So Young. Don't mean that you have to dismiss one sound and prefer the other - but strange if you don't hear any difference.

listen, youngster. when you're as old as the hills like me, you'll find it strange you can hear anything at all.

You are older than me? I thought you simply were taller

older, taller, stupider...the list goes on and on. i'm beginning to take a dislike to you. i take back all the nice things i've said about you...wait...did i say something nice? oh...yeah, on the dylan thread. and i take back that cigar i gave you in london...hmmm...probable got your spittle all over it by now...so you can keep that...but it's the last one you get....

Quote
StonesTod

Quote
Erik_Snow

Quote
StonesTod

Quote
Erik_Snow

Quote
StonesTod

Quote
Erik_Snow

Quote
StonesTod

Quote
Erik_Snow

Quote
DandelionPowderman
The sound, for starters?

Yes, indeed, the sound

bollocks. if someone had told you this was stu on piano, everyone would be singing the praises of the mighty ian stewart. the fact is that chuck is a master of all styles...it's why stu picked him...chuck can do stu, nicky, billy...and just about anyone else....now, please stop the chuck bashing and let's back to our regularly scheduled ronnie and keith bashings....

No there's a big difference in sound. Compare Key To The Highway on Dirty Work with Fancyman Blues from 1989 for instance, for a prime example.

the way the piano is recorded is your criticism now? i give up....

i understand your need to find a fall guy, erik...but there's not enough evidence to convict this guy...i ask the judge to throw the case out....

THat's not right - that I need to find a fall guy; I mean. We obviously have a different view on his playing; but you try to turn it into the standard "you just bash Chuck because of the fact that Rolling Stones themselves have declined" thingy. But that's not what I'm doing.

Strange if you don't hear any difference between classic piano sound and keyboard ala Fancyman Blues and So Young. Don't mean that you have to dismiss one sound and prefer the other - but strange if you don't hear any difference.

listen, youngster. when you're as old as the hills like me, you'll find it strange you can hear anything at all.

You are older than me? I thought you simply were taller

older, taller, stupider...the list goes on and on. i'm beginning to take a dislike to you. i take back all the nice things i've said about you...wait...did i say something nice? oh...yeah, on the dylan thread. and i take back that cigar i gave you in london...hmmm...probable got your spittle all over it by now...so you can keep that...but it's the last one you get....

You take everything back? Even the cigar? Oh no - please don't.....thought you'd take being taller as a compliment.

Chuck is tearing this family apart too..

Quote
Erik_Snow

Quote
StonesTod

Quote
Erik_Snow

Quote
StonesTod

Quote
Erik_Snow

Quote
StonesTod

Quote
Erik_Snow

Quote
StonesTod

Quote
Erik_Snow

Quote
DandelionPowderman
The sound, for starters?

Yes, indeed, the sound

bollocks. if someone had told you this was stu on piano, everyone would be singing the praises of the mighty ian stewart. the fact is that chuck is a master of all styles...it's why stu picked him...chuck can do stu, nicky, billy...and just about anyone else....now, please stop the chuck bashing and let's back to our regularly scheduled ronnie and keith bashings....

No there's a big difference in sound. Compare Key To The Highway on Dirty Work with Fancyman Blues from 1989 for instance, for a prime example.

the way the piano is recorded is your criticism now? i give up....

i understand your need to find a fall guy, erik...but there's not enough evidence to convict this guy...i ask the judge to throw the case out....

THat's not right - that I need to find a fall guy; I mean. We obviously have a different view on his playing; but you try to turn it into the standard "you just bash Chuck because of the fact that Rolling Stones themselves have declined" thingy. But that's not what I'm doing.

Strange if you don't hear any difference between classic piano sound and keyboard ala Fancyman Blues and So Young. Don't mean that you have to dismiss one sound and prefer the other - but strange if you don't hear any difference.

listen, youngster. when you're as old as the hills like me, you'll find it strange you can hear anything at all.

You are older than me? I thought you simply were taller

older, taller, stupider...the list goes on and on. i'm beginning to take a dislike to you. i take back all the nice things i've said about you...wait...did i say something nice? oh...yeah, on the dylan thread. and i take back that cigar i gave you in london...hmmm...probable got your spittle all over it by now...so you can keep that...but it's the last one you get....

You take everything back? Even the cigar? Oh no - please don't.....thought you'd take being taller as a compliment.

the stupider comment is the one that did it, erik. wait, that was my comment...see what happens when you get old??

Quote
StonesTod

Quote
Erik_Snow

Quote
StonesTod

Quote
Erik_Snow

Quote
StonesTod

Quote
Erik_Snow

Quote
StonesTod

Quote
Erik_Snow

Quote
StonesTod

Quote
Erik_Snow

Quote
DandelionPowderman
The sound, for starters?

Yes, indeed, the sound

bollocks. if someone had told you this was stu on piano, everyone would be singing the praises of the mighty ian stewart. the fact is that chuck is a master of all styles...it's why stu picked him...chuck can do stu, nicky, billy...and just about anyone else....now, please stop the chuck bashing and let's back to our regularly scheduled ronnie and keith bashings....

No there's a big difference in sound. Compare Key To The Highway on Dirty Work with Fancyman Blues from 1989 for instance, for a prime example.

the way the piano is recorded is your criticism now? i give up....

i understand your need to find a fall guy, erik...but there's not enough evidence to convict this guy...i ask the judge to throw the case out....

THat's not right - that I need to find a fall guy; I mean. We obviously have a different view on his playing; but you try to turn it into the standard "you just bash Chuck because of the fact that Rolling Stones themselves have declined" thingy. But that's not what I'm doing.

Strange if you don't hear any difference between classic piano sound and keyboard ala Fancyman Blues and So Young. Don't mean that you have to dismiss one sound and prefer the other - but strange if you don't hear any difference.

listen, youngster. when you're as old as the hills like me, you'll find it strange you can hear anything at all.

You are older than me? I thought you simply were taller

older, taller, stupider...the list goes on and on. i'm beginning to take a dislike to you. i take back all the nice things i've said about you...wait...did i say something nice? oh...yeah, on the dylan thread. and i take back that cigar i gave you in london...hmmm...probable got your spittle all over it by now...so you can keep that...but it's the last one you get....

You take everything back? Even the cigar? Oh no - please don't.....thought you'd take being taller as a compliment.

the stupider comment is the one that did it, erik. wait, that was my comment...see what happens when you get old??

Stupider....yes that was your comment. In fact being just taller was my way of being polite... and pretend that you look as young and innocent as me....to make up for the piano/keyboard discussion

DAMN YOU CHUCK!!!!!
DAMN YOU!!!

Quote
Munichhilton
Chuck is tearing this family apart too..

but it's all stu's fault. he picked chuck. yes, chuck tore, but stu picked.

Quote
Munichhilton
DAMN YOU CHUCK!!!!!
DAMN YOU!!!

Are you quoting Peppermint Patty here?

Quote
Erik_Snow

Quote
Munichhilton
DAMN YOU CHUCK!!!!!
DAMN YOU!!!

Are you quoting Peppermint Patty here?

Quote
Erik_Snow

Quote
Munichhilton
DAMN YOU CHUCK!!!!!
DAMN YOU!!!

Are you quoting Peppermint Patty here?

What if I were?
Will it put this family back together?

I guess I do need to take Vince Guaraldi CD off the heavy rotation

vince rocks...he does a better cast your fate to the wind than the james gang.

Quote
Deltics

Quote
LeonidP

Quote
Munichhilton

Quote
LeonidP
piano version here:

Excellent work...but watch out
I hear bv is in the waters

Not allowed? I noticed someone else posted another version before.

[www.iorr.org]

Am I allowed to post this?

[www.kboing.com.br]

Drew

Thanks! Nice outtake

[downloadbox.net]

Find it here!

Wooa! This little gem is without a doubt the biggest surprise of the Some Girls deluxe.

It's a real boogie and it's got some serious attitude!