For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
swiss
This is fantastic. What do you think is live and what's recorded? I think Mick's vocals are live, backup vocals obviously not, not sure about Keith's solo, don't think Brian is playing piano tho my friend says he is
-swiss
Quote
swiss
This is fantastic. What do you think is live and what's recorded? I think Mick's vocals are live, backup vocals obviously not, not sure about Keith's solo, don't think Brian is playing piano tho my friend says he is
-swiss
Quote
24FPS
It's Pythonesque with the incongruity between the Stones and the staid, mostly older female audience.
Quote
ghostryder13
seems like there's a few extra guitar notes that are not found on the album version.probably an alternate mix made for tv use
Quote
aplata
Amazing footage of the Stones performing one of the best songs in rock history. This video really demonstrates how versatile a musician Brian was. It also makes me start to think if he should have received credit for playing piano for sympathy because the August 9, 1969 Rolling Stone Article dedicated to Jones says that he played countrified steel guitar and piano on Beggars Banquet ( [www.rollingstone.com] ). As we all know Mick and Keith gave credit to Nicky Hopkins. The band obviously made sure that Brian would receive small parts in the video. Which only goes to show that there was tension between Brian and the rest of the band at the time. However, it is still great to get a chance to see and hear him play an amazing piano part.
I don't know why the audiophiles are saying that Keith might not be playing guitar and Brian is not playing piano. On the version I saw on youtube clearly they are both playing their parts.
I will never forget you Brian and your contribution to Rock music.
Quote
Deltics
You are aware that Jagger was singing live over a backing track aren't you?
The rest of the Stones, including Brian, are miming. The reason why everybody credits Nicky Hopkins for playing piano is because he did!
I've never heard of anyone, audiophile or not, suggesting that Keith didn't play guitar.