Clearly someone is impressed in the studio after her "Murder" so nicely shouted
You noticed it. There is a kind of "waouh" .... recorded on the tape. Who ?

"we know it's a bit late but we hope you don't mind if we stay"

I have no idea what you are talking about. Please explain more

-------------------
Keep On Rolling

I hear it, sounds like Jagger.

That's Jagger, sounds like a "yeah!"

Ms. Clayton said Jagger was impressed with how high she could sing and tried to follow her voice, which made her laugh. She was heavily pregnant when she recorded that vocal.

yep...sounds like Jagger

I you listen to the multi track recording you hear it twice on in between and one at the end if I have the time I will extract the part and post it on you tube..I think it's Jagger because he seemed impressed by the voice of MC

__________________________

Here you go...........................PLAY IT LOUD WHOA at 23 and 31
(I didn't use any name in the clip because it looks like every time I upload some thing from the multi track recordings it will be removed by You Tube)





__________________________

Definatly Jagger

yeah - jagger.

love that part - so awesome

Thanks Nicos

-------------------
Keep On Rolling

Quote
crumbling_mice
Definatly Jagger

I'm not doubting you, but how can you say with such conviction that it's "definitely Jagger"??? It could be anyone.

Quote
NICOS
Here you go...........................PLAY IT LOUD WHOA at 23 and 31
(I didn't use any name in the clip because it looks like every time I upload some thing from the multi track recordings it will be removed by You Tube)

Cool clip!

Very cool clip NICOS, thanks. Searing vocal from Clayton. Whoa's and whoo's gotta be MJ. How could he not respond? Wouldn't you?

Nicos that was way cool! Man thanks for that, sitting at my desk winding down the day and i get to hear Clayton lay it on the boys and hear Mick testifying to her brilliance. Mick all the way.

Thanks for the clip, love it

Great thread. I have always thought the 2 whoops is Keith. It sounds like Keith to me.

Since it's unanimous that it's Mick, I will give it another listen, but for the moment I'm sticking with: it's Keith

- swiss

Fantastic clip, Nicos. Thanks for sharing. Just amazing to hear it so clearly.

Quote
riffhard72

Quote
crumbling_mice
Definatly Jagger

I'm not doubting you, but how can you say with such conviction that it's "definitely Jagger"??? It could be anyone.

I've listened to it on some really top of the range speakers at a considerable volume and it's Jagger, you can tell by the voice and the way he does the whoop - Keith doesn't whoop and I doubt would have done at that particular era in the studio. I can't be 100%, but I'd say 98% Jagger

Quote
riffhard72

Quote
crumbling_mice
Definatly Jagger

I'm not doubting you, but how can you say with such conviction that it's "definitely Jagger"??? It could be anyone.

How can yo not? Definately Mick, a signature whoop...
Jagger's got the greatest WHOOOOP in rock and roll.

Quote
riffhard72
...how can you say with such conviction that it's "definitely Jagger"??? It could be anyone.

Oh, alright, it's definitely Charlie then. Only Charlie can pull a Mick Jagger like that.

>> Keith doesn't whoop <<

sure he does! whoops yeahs wos and ha-hos right along with the best of 'em :E
but in Gimmie Shelter it's Mick

Quote
skipstone

Quote
riffhard72
...how can you say with such conviction that it's "definitely Jagger"??? It could be anyone.

Oh, alright, it's definitely Charlie then. Only Charlie can pull a Mick Jagger like that.

Bill - definitely Bill. Apparently he was a madman in the studio - jumping around and whooping. It was only on stage that he stood motionless.

Quote
Roll73

Quote
skipstone

Quote
riffhard72
...how can you say with such conviction that it's "definitely Jagger"??? It could be anyone.

Oh, alright, it's definitely Charlie then. Only Charlie can pull a Mick Jagger like that.

Bill - definitely Bill. Apparently he was a madman in the studio - jumping around and whooping. It was only on stage that he stood motionless.

Ah! All right. You're right! Mick Taylor it was then! Even though he didn't play on Gimme Shelter, he was obviously there, giving Merry a lot of support since she obviously needed it...

Assuming Bonnie didn't pass the contest neither did Keith (at least I don't here him on the original GS) only Mick and Merry are singing on GS so it must be Mick........................

Would love to hear the Bonnie Bramlett version................................



__________________________

Quote
NICOS
Assuming Bonnie didn't pass the contest neither did Keith (at least I don't here him on the original GS) only Mick and Merry are singing on GS so it must be Mick........................

Would love to hear the Bonnie Bramlett version................................

I'd love to hear the Bonnie version also!

Keith does sing harmony on the original GS btw.