Tell Me :
Talk
+1
i agree! I love dead flowers from Stripped better than sticky fingers
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2010-07-27 21:14 by marchbaby.
Seriously....is there a cut on Ya-Yas that isn't better than the studio version?...I think every single song is a notch better...
Yes! I was about to add to the above sentence "So does "Sympathy", so does "Stray Cat Blues"...etc.
Interesting choices, and I agree with them all.
Of course I will add:
Midnight Rambler
Out of control
Dead Flowers
I know these have all been mentioned but I concur they're usually even better live.
WOW. Are you serious? Those are atrocities on Shine A Light! It's amazing they were even considered to be on the album yet alone put on the album and even in the damn movie!!!!
Talk about your favorite band.
For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
What Stones song(s) do you prefer the Live version better than the studio recordered verison?
Posted by:
marchbaby
()
Date: July 27, 2010 20:02
For me it would have to be Connection & You Got the Silver from the Shine A Light CD versus their original recorded studio version.
Re: What Stones song(s) do you prefer the Live version better than the studio recordered verison?
Posted by:
Rocky Dijon
()
Date: July 27, 2010 20:05
I can think of four...
Midnight Rambler on GET YER YA-YA'S OUT
Hot Stuff on LOVE YOU LIVE
When the Whip Comes Down on SUCKING IN THE SEVENTIES
Just My Imagination on STILL LIFE
Midnight Rambler on GET YER YA-YA'S OUT
Hot Stuff on LOVE YOU LIVE
When the Whip Comes Down on SUCKING IN THE SEVENTIES
Just My Imagination on STILL LIFE
Re: What Stones song(s) do you prefer the Live version better than the studio recordered verison?
Posted by:
Amused
()
Date: July 27, 2010 20:08
many, many... most of their songs... depends on year and tour, mostly.
Sweet Black Angel... Love In Vain... Angie: they just need electricity
Midnight Rambler, of course... harder... blues opera, wow...
Live With Me, a special one live... stronger, too
Sympathy for the Devil from 1969... absolutely...
You Got Me Rocking, it's meant as a sing-along...
Worried About You, it was just @#$%& brilliant live
those first came to my mind.
the other way: Brown Sugar was never so cool live as in studio, what else...
Stray Cat Blues, Sway, etc
Sweet Black Angel... Love In Vain... Angie: they just need electricity
Midnight Rambler, of course... harder... blues opera, wow...
Live With Me, a special one live... stronger, too
Sympathy for the Devil from 1969... absolutely...
You Got Me Rocking, it's meant as a sing-along...
Worried About You, it was just @#$%& brilliant live
those first came to my mind.
the other way: Brown Sugar was never so cool live as in studio, what else...
Stray Cat Blues, Sway, etc
Re: What Stones song(s) do you prefer the Live version better than the studio recordered verison?
Posted by:
dancingmisterd
()
Date: July 27, 2010 20:12
Quote
Amused
Sympathy for the Devil from 1969... absolutely...
+1
Re: What Stones song(s) do you prefer the Live version better than the studio recordered verison?
Posted by:
ghostryder13
()
Date: July 27, 2010 20:17
midnight rambler (ya ya's)
star star (love you live)
i'm free (ya ya's deluxe)
star star (love you live)
i'm free (ya ya's deluxe)
Re: What Stones song(s) do you prefer the Live version better than the studio recordered verison?
Posted by:
Reagan
()
Date: July 27, 2010 20:25
The big ones (much better than studio versions)
Street Fighting Man from Ya Ya's
Jumping Jack Flash from the Gimme Shelter movie (taken from the 1st show 11/28/69 in NYC)
Better, but not a huge improvement
Carol from Ya Ya's
Honkey Tonk Women from Ya Ya's (or the Gimme Shelter movie, both were brilliant)
I'm Free from San Diego show 1969 (the arrangement of it from the early shows on that tour was great)
Pretty much a tie with the studio version
No Expectations from Hyde Park
Gimme Shelter from the Philadelphia show 7/21/1972 - blistering Mick Taylor work, but does lose out on Merry Clayton
Finally, it never was a studio release, but The Sun Is Shining from Altamont would be hard to top.
Edited 3 time(s). Last edit at 2010-07-28 20:24 by Reagan.
Street Fighting Man from Ya Ya's
Jumping Jack Flash from the Gimme Shelter movie (taken from the 1st show 11/28/69 in NYC)
Better, but not a huge improvement
Carol from Ya Ya's
Honkey Tonk Women from Ya Ya's (or the Gimme Shelter movie, both were brilliant)
I'm Free from San Diego show 1969 (the arrangement of it from the early shows on that tour was great)
Pretty much a tie with the studio version
No Expectations from Hyde Park
Gimme Shelter from the Philadelphia show 7/21/1972 - blistering Mick Taylor work, but does lose out on Merry Clayton
Finally, it never was a studio release, but The Sun Is Shining from Altamont would be hard to top.
Edited 3 time(s). Last edit at 2010-07-28 20:24 by Reagan.
Re: What Stones song(s) do you prefer the Live version better than the studio recordered verison?
Posted by:
mitchflorida
()
Date: July 27, 2010 20:55
Dead Flowers is so much better live than on the studio version. MT never ceases to amaze me on this performance.
Re: What Stones song(s) do you prefer the Live version better than the studio recordered verison?
Posted by:
marchbaby
()
Date: July 27, 2010 21:14
Quote
mitchflorida
Dead Flowers is so much better live than on the studio version. MT never ceases to amaze me on this performance.
i agree! I love dead flowers from Stripped better than sticky fingers
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2010-07-27 21:14 by marchbaby.
Re: What Stones song(s) do you prefer the Live version better than the studio recordered verison?
Posted by:
kleermaker
()
Date: July 27, 2010 21:17
Quote
Reagan
Finally, it never was a studio release, but The Sun Is Shining from Altamont would be hard to top.
Re: What Stones song(s) do you prefer the Live version better than the studio recordered verison?
Posted by:
Reagan
()
Date: July 27, 2010 21:32
Kleermaker, That's the stuff, alright. Thanks.
-R
-R
Re: What Stones song(s) do you prefer the Live version better than the studio recordered verison?
Posted by:
Thommie
()
Date: July 27, 2010 23:48
Wanna hold you
If you can't rock me
It's only rock'n roll
If you can't rock me
It's only rock'n roll
Re: What Stones song(s) do you prefer the Live version better than the studio recordered verison?
Posted by:
sweet neo con
()
Date: July 27, 2010 23:52
I like the faster LIVE version of LET ME GO....I wish the studio version was faster.
Re: What Stones song(s) do you prefer the Live version better than the studio recordered verison?
Posted by:
TeaAtThree
()
Date: July 28, 2010 01:45
Satisfaction from Gimme Shelter film -- the smoking solo and the outro vocals keep it raunchy.
JJF from just about any era. The riff just gets thicker and thicker.
JJF from just about any era. The riff just gets thicker and thicker.
Re: What Stones song(s) do you prefer the Live version better than the studio recordered verison?
Posted by:
urbanjungle90
()
Date: July 28, 2010 01:52
Rather than individual versions of songs as people have said here, I mostly prefer the live versions on a whole, great as the studio versions are. I listen to more live performances than studio versions of songs. That is one of the reasons I like the Stones, because they're such a strong live band.
Re: What Stones song(s) do you prefer the Live version better than the studio recordered verison?
Posted by:
robertcharles
()
Date: July 28, 2010 01:55
So many but you need the original.Otherwise you can,t compare them.
And Marchbaby,The intro from You got the silver in Sal is completely messed up by Ronnie .He didn,t rehaerse it -Wrong chords stucture-progression.
Robertcharles
And Marchbaby,The intro from You got the silver in Sal is completely messed up by Ronnie .He didn,t rehaerse it -Wrong chords stucture-progression.
Robertcharles
Re: What Stones song(s) do you prefer the Live version better than the studio recordered verison?
Posted by:
71Tele
()
Date: July 28, 2010 01:58
Midnight Rambler, Live With Me, Love In Vain on Ya-Yas all vastly exceed their studio versions. So do the two Chuck Berry tunes.
If you count unofficial releases, I have to add "Dancing With Mr. D", "Angie", and "You Can't Always Get What You Want" from Brussels '73.
If you count unofficial releases, I have to add "Dancing With Mr. D", "Angie", and "You Can't Always Get What You Want" from Brussels '73.
Re: What Stones song(s) do you prefer the Live version better than the studio recordered verison?
Posted by:
polythene sam
()
Date: July 28, 2010 03:26
Midnight Rambler
Out Of Control
Saint Of Me
Out Of Control
Saint Of Me
Re: What Stones song(s) do you prefer the Live version better than the studio recordered verison?
Posted by:
BluzDude
()
Date: July 28, 2010 04:10
Midnight Rambler
Out Of Control
Out Of Control
Re: What Stones song(s) do you prefer the Live version better than the studio recordered verison?
Posted by:
palerider22
()
Date: July 28, 2010 04:40
Quote
71Tele
Midnight Rambler, Live With Me, Love In Vain on Ya-Yas all vastly exceed their studio versions. So do the two Chuck Berry tunes.
If you count unofficial releases, I have to add "Dancing With Mr. D", "Angie", and "You Can't Always Get What You Want" from Brussels '73.
Seriously....is there a cut on Ya-Yas that isn't better than the studio version?...I think every single song is a notch better...
Re: What Stones song(s) do you prefer the Live version better than the studio recordered verison?
Posted by:
71Tele
()
Date: July 28, 2010 04:46
Quote
palerider22Quote
71Tele
Midnight Rambler, Live With Me, Love In Vain on Ya-Yas all vastly exceed their studio versions. So do the two Chuck Berry tunes.
If you count unofficial releases, I have to add "Dancing With Mr. D", "Angie", and "You Can't Always Get What You Want" from Brussels '73.
Seriously....is there a cut on Ya-Yas that isn't better than the studio version?...I think every single song is a notch better...
Yes! I was about to add to the above sentence "So does "Sympathy", so does "Stray Cat Blues"...etc.
Re: What Stones song(s) do you prefer the Live version better than the studio recordered verison?
Posted by:
sirdoug
()
Date: July 28, 2010 04:57
Every track from Ya-Ya's...my favorite Stones record of them all
Re: What Stones song(s) do you prefer the Live version better than the studio recordered verison?
Posted by:
keefriffhard4life
()
Date: July 28, 2010 04:58
fingerprint file from love you live. i can't even stand the studio version
Re: What Stones song(s) do you prefer the Live version better than the studio recordered verison?
Posted by:
TippyToe
()
Date: July 28, 2010 05:22
Carol and Little Queenie from Ya Ya's.
Re: What Stones song(s) do you prefer the Live version better than the studio recordered verison?
Posted by:
theimposter
()
Date: July 28, 2010 05:43
Quote
Thommie
Wanna hold you
If you can't rock me
It's only rock'n roll
Interesting choices, and I agree with them all.
Of course I will add:
Midnight Rambler
Out of control
Dead Flowers
I know these have all been mentioned but I concur they're usually even better live.
Re: What Stones song(s) do you prefer the Live version better than the studio recordered verison?
Posted by:
microvibe
()
Date: July 28, 2010 05:49
everything from get yer ya yas out!
Re: What Stones song(s) do you prefer the Live version better than the studio recordered verison?
Posted by:
Doc
()
Date: July 28, 2010 13:03
Sympathy For The Devil (GYYYO and Atlantic City)
Midnight Rambler ( almost any era live version)
You Got Me Rocking
Satisfaction
Worried About You
Dance Pt 1
Streets Of Love
[doctorstonesblog.blogspot.com]
Midnight Rambler ( almost any era live version)
You Got Me Rocking
Satisfaction
Worried About You
Dance Pt 1
Streets Of Love
[doctorstonesblog.blogspot.com]
Re: What Stones song(s) do you prefer the Live version better than the studio recordered verison?
Posted by:
whitem8
()
Date: July 28, 2010 13:56
She's So Cold from A Bigger Bang, surprisingly good!
All of GYYYO! Definitive versions of every song.
All of GYYYO! Definitive versions of every song.
Re: What Stones song(s) do you prefer the Live version better than the studio recordered verison?
Posted by:
Tantekäthe
()
Date: July 28, 2010 17:31
Next to many of the tracks mentioned already, I particularly like "The Last Time" from the NS album whereas I can't be bothered by the original studio version.
Someone mentioned Live With Me as well; I would like to know if a listenable live version of that song is available (you know, not those one-note staccato vocals, and with some rhythm guitar that at least vaguely matches the original).
Someone mentioned Live With Me as well; I would like to know if a listenable live version of that song is available (you know, not those one-note staccato vocals, and with some rhythm guitar that at least vaguely matches the original).
Re: What Stones song(s) do you prefer the Live version better than the studio recordered verison?
Posted by:
skipstone
()
Date: July 28, 2010 17:35
Quote
marchbaby
For me it would have to be Connection & You Got the Silver from the Shine A Light CD versus their original recorded studio version.
WOW. Are you serious? Those are atrocities on Shine A Light! It's amazing they were even considered to be on the album yet alone put on the album and even in the damn movie!!!!
Re: What Stones song(s) do you prefer the Live version better than the studio recordered verison?
Posted by:
RITA
()
Date: July 28, 2010 17:38
Out of Control!
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
Online Users
Guests:
449
Record Number of Users:
206
on June 1, 2022 23:50
Record Number of Guests:
9627
on January 2, 2024 23:10