I will ask Buddy Guy what the hell is macho-blues

Pass The Wine - 4
Plundered My Soul - 6
I'm Not Signifying - 9
Following The River - 2
Dancing In The Light - 6
So Divine - 8
Loving Cup - 8
Soul Survivor - 5
Good Time Women - 5
Title 5 - 4

+ All Down The Line - 6



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2010-07-01 14:21 by claudine.

Well, if I had to rate the new Exile song within the Stones body of work no tune would be better than 7 at best to me!

But just for the extra songs it would be like this:

Wine 5
Plundered 8
Signifying 8
River 8
Dancing 6
So Divine 7
Loving Cup 5
Soul Survivor 7 (+ 1 extra point for Keith voice)
Good Time W. 6
Title 5 6

Pass The Wine - 5
Plundered My Soul - 7
I'm Not Signifying - 8
Following The River - 2
Dancing In The Light - 9
So Divine - 8
Loving Cup - 6
Soul Survivor - 8
Good Time Women - 8
Title 5 - 8

...I've been a concert promoter for over 12 years (1,200 max.cap. concert hall), doing loads of garage/ surf/ 'monstro'/ psychobilly stuff; and although "Title 5" doesn't really shift boundaries or break down walls in those departments, it is a highly 'credibile' track indeed- it does stand out for me, as a Stones track. I just never thought the Boys would pull one like that; and with such ease, swagger, finesse & authenticity... ànd with that typical 'trainwreck/ crashing airplane' ending!! Luvit- I profoundly regret it's just a mere 1'50"...

Quote
Filip020169
Pass The Wine - 5
Plundered My Soul - 7
I'm Not Signifying - 8
Following The River - 2
Dancing In The Light - 9
So Divine - 8
Loving Cup - 6
Soul Survivor - 8
Good Time Women - 8
Title 5 - 8

...I've been a concert promoter for over 12 years (1,200 max.cap. concert hall), doing loads of garage/ surf/ 'monstro'/ psychobilly stuff; and although "Title 5" doesn't really shift boundaries or break down walls in those departments, it is a highly 'credibile' track indeed- it does stand out for me, as a Stones track. I just never thought the Boys would pull one like that; and with such ease, swagger, finesse & authenticity... ànd with that typical 'trainwreck/ crashing airplane' ending!! Luvit- I profoundly regret it's just a mere 1'50"...

This is perhaps the most mysterious of Stones tracks. Mathjis thinks it is from the Between The Buttons sessions, and indeed it sounds out of place on Exile. But supposedly all tracks come from the "Exile period".

By this reasoning, Dirty Work could have 10s on it. I don't think so.

Quote
71Tele

This is perhaps the most mysterious of Stones tracks. Mathjis thinks it is from the Between The Buttons sessions, and indeed it sounds out of place on Exile. But supposedly all tracks come from the "Exile period".

...true. It doesn't sound very '72 to me, either.

And there's something else that puzzles me: the line-up (in the liner notes) only mentions Keith on guitar; but I hear 2 guitars...
Off course, overdubs can be the answer; but the intro ("Title 5... take one..." ) suggests it's live & in one take, doesn't it?!

Quote
Filip020169

Quote
71Tele

This is perhaps the most mysterious of Stones tracks. Mathjis thinks it is from the Between The Buttons sessions, and indeed it sounds out of place on Exile. But supposedly all tracks come from the "Exile period".

...true. It doesn't sound very '72 to me, either.

And there's something else that puzzles me: the line-up (in the liner notes) only mentions Keith on guitar; but I hear 2 guitars...
Off course, overdubs can be the answer; but the intro ("Title 5... take one..." ) suggests it's live & in one take, doesn't it?!

if the exile period includes sessions for let it bleed and sticky fingers.where most songs were started (and maybe earlier)

Quote
ricardosanchez
Pass The Wine - 10
Plundered My Soul - 10
I'm Not Signifying - 10
Following The River - 9
Dancing In The Light - 7
So Divine - 8
Loving Cup - 11
Soul Survivor - 8
Good Time Women - 8.5
Title 5 - 8
*All Down The Line (Amazon) - 10

for me this is extremely accurate including all down the line rating

Pass The Wine - 9
Plundered My Soul - 9
I'm Not Signifying - 8
Following The River - 10
Dancing In The Light - 6
So Divine - 10
Loving Cup - 8
Soul Survivor - 8
Good Time Women - 9
Title 5 - 7


after listening round 50 times....

Pass The Wine - 6
Plundered My Soul - 8
I'm Not Signifying - 8
Following The River - 9
Dancing In The Light - 8
So Devine - 7 - COULD BE A REAL GROWER THO
Loving Cup - 6 - CANT SEE WHY I WOULD EVER PLAY IT OVER THE EXILE VERSION
Soul Survivor - 6 REALLY INTERESTING....BUT NOT ENDURING
Good Time Women - 8 GREAT VIBE
Title 5 - 5 - WEIRD LITTLE THROWAWAY