For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
georgelicks
The vocals are from 2020, I don't know how some people don't hear it, Mick didn't sing like that in 1974.
Keith vocals are from 1974, most of Mick's new vocals are very well double tracked with Keith, it works great and that's why some people can be confused.
The credits were the confusing part for me.
Why do they present wrong credits again and again?
Quote
Four Stone Walls
Anyway, it doesn't belong on a Goats Head Soup reissue.
Next?!
Quote
Erik_SnowQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
georgelicks
The vocals are from 2020, I don't know how some people don't hear it, Mick didn't sing like that in 1974.
Keith vocals are from 1974, most of Mick's new vocals are very well double tracked with Keith, it works great and that's why some people can be confused.
The credits were the confusing part for me.
Why do they present wrong credits again and again?
Because nobody remembers anything. Bill Wyman would have, but he wasn't present. Jimmy Page is pretending to remember, he's not as frank as he was in that 1986 interview in admitting that
Quote
georgemcdonnell314
Look what they did with some of the tracks on the Exile reissue it is obvious that things were changed for us to believe they were from Exile when in fact they were not.
Quote
Rip This
the more listens, the better this track sounds...
Quote
Stoneage
If Ronnie wasn't there (which seems a bit strange since they recorded in his basement) and the lyrics were added afterwards: Was Keith the only Stone to participate on that song?
And in that case - is it a Rolling Stones song then?
Quote
Stoneage
If Ronnie wasn't there (which seems a bit strange since they recorded in his basement) and the lyrics were added afterwards: Was Keith the only Stone to participate on that song?
And in that case - is it a Rolling Stones song then?
Quote
Stoneage
If Ronnie wasn't there (which seems a bit strange since they recorded in his basement) and the lyrics were added afterwards: Was Keith the only Stone to participate on that song?
And in that case - is it a Rolling Stones song then?
Quote
HairballQuote
Stoneage
If Ronnie wasn't there (which seems a bit strange since they recorded in his basement) and the lyrics were added afterwards: Was Keith the only Stone to participate on that song?
And in that case - is it a Rolling Stones song then?
I pointed that fact out earlier, and my answer was 'not really'...it's all questionable at best.
But slap some Jagger 2020 vocals on it, and evidently they can call it a Stones song with many fans falling for it.
Quote
HairballQuote
Stoneage
If Ronnie wasn't there (which seems a bit strange since they recorded in his basement) and the lyrics were added afterwards: Was Keith the only Stone to participate on that song?
And in that case - is it a Rolling Stones song then?
I pointed that fact out earlier, and my answer was 'not really'...it's all questionable at best.
But slap some Jagger 2020 vocals on it, and evidently they can call it a Stones song with many fans falling for it.
Quote
stone4ever
Maybe Keith and Jimmy should make an album together, they gell together surprisingly well, get a few guest singers in on a few tracks, Keith take care of the rest, beats waiting forever for a lousy Stones Jagger solo album.
Quote
MisterDDDDQuote
HairballQuote
Stoneage
If Ronnie wasn't there (which seems a bit strange since they recorded in his basement) and the lyrics were added afterwards: Was Keith the only Stone to participate on that song?
And in that case - is it a Rolling Stones song then?
I pointed that fact out earlier, and my answer was 'not really'...it's all questionable at best.
But slap some Jagger 2020 vocals on it, and evidently they can call it a Stones song with many fans falling for it.
Yup.
Gotta get up prettttty early in the mornin' to get one by y'all
If only there was some type of precedence.. or many lists and several threads of all "The Rolling Stones" songs that didn't involve all the members.. Good catch .. It's Only Rock And Roll.
[ultimateclassicrock.com]
Quote
MisterDDDDQuote
stone4ever
Maybe Keith and Jimmy should make an album together, they gell together surprisingly well, get a few guest singers in on a few tracks, Keith take care of the rest, beats waiting forever for a lousy Stones Jagger solo album.
You sound mad.
You mad, bro??
Quote
stone4everQuote
MisterDDDDQuote
stone4ever
Maybe Keith and Jimmy should make an album together, they gell together surprisingly well, get a few guest singers in on a few tracks, Keith take care of the rest, beats waiting forever for a lousy Stones Jagger solo album.
You sound mad.
You mad, bro??
NO